508 - BR03_POST2305109_Satterfield,_Joshua_Attachment_A_Redacted_Termination_Letter.pdf
About this document
- Layer
- packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
- Type as titled
- case_attachment (kind from title)
- File
- 63d552b96f35b443028446e20a1204ce6e11e2ca application/pdf
- Cases
About: Joshua Satterfield (case)
Joshua Satterfield
September 22, 2022
Page 8 of 14
III. ANALYSIS
In Skelly v. State Personnel Board (1975) 15 Cal.3d 194, the California Supreme Court stated that the “overriding consideration” when addressing whether a public employer has imposed an appropriate level of discipline is “the extent to which the employee’s conduct resulted in, or if repeated, is likely to result in, ‘harm to the public service.’” (Id. at 218.) “Other relevant factors include the circumstances surrounding the misconduct and the likelihood of its recurrence.” (Id.) In your particular case, the principles set forth in Skelly amply support your proposed discipline. In fact, the period between May 2018 through September 2019 establishes an ongoing pattern of misconduct and policy violations.
A. YOU ENGAGED IN INEXCUSABLE MISCONDUCT
1. You Exchanged Discriminatory and Inappropriate Text Messages with TPD Coworkers
Your involvement in discriminatory text messaging with other TPD officers demonstrates an extreme lack of sound decision-making and unbecoming conduct that calls into question your fitness for duty as a police officer. You sent, received, and otherwise interacted with/responded to multiple blatantly discriminatory text messages from other members of TPD for over a year. You used racial slurs, as well as the “N” word in conversations with your colleagues, and engaged in homophobic and transphobic “jokes”. The casual use of these terms between you and the other officers indicates that this type of conduct was not unusual between you. Particularly alarming, you made multiple jokes about Black individuals from real Torrance police officer –involved shootings. In one, you state the officer should have been a better shot so he could have killed the Black individual. In another you state the deceased’s surviving son will be fine because it is the “norm” in Black communities to grow up without a father.
Such racist, homophobic, and inappropriate content has no place in this Department. Whether or not these messages were intended as “jokes” does not exempt them from the City’s harassment policies. In fact, the policy clearly defines visual/ written harassment as “The display or circulation of offensive or derogatory visual or written material related to race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry...” among other protected classifications. The content contained within the text messages in question here clearly fall within these parameters. By engaging in these messages, you engaged in inappropriate speech and unprofessional conduct in violation of multiple City policies, including Policy Nos. 319.5.1(a), 319.5.7(i), 319.5.8(f),(g),(m), and 1021.4(b), and former General Orders 1.10.3(B), 2.01.1(A), and 2.33.1(D). This conduct also violated the City’s Anti-Harassment Policy. Moreover, you should have reported any discriminatory messages you received by a fellow Officer as soon as you received it.
This Department relies on its officers to uphold the highest standards of conduct to maintain positive relationships and preserve the trust we have with the community we serve. You demonstrated bias here that erodes that trust and smears the reputation of this Department. This Department already experienced the damage to its reputation when the news media published what were then unverified accounts of these text messages starting in August 2021. Now that the investigation has substantiated at least some of the allegations, the breach in community trust is cemented.
3031 Torrance Boulevard • Torrance, California 90503 • Telephone 310/618-5880 • Fax 310/618-5891
Visit Torrance’s home page: <http://www.TorranceCA.Gov>
35
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.