Documents › 58590b04707e3895dcd810727eb33b7af4d3b69f:2013-2016

648 - BR16_POST2410050_O_Fonthal_Final_ROI_Redacted.pdf

POST board investigation reportagency investigation 2025-12-02 4 pages (file pages 2013–2016) original file
About this document
Layer
packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
Type as titled
case_attachment (kind from title)
File
58590b04707e3895dcd810727eb33b7af4d3b69f application/pdf
Cases
POST 2410050 · Michael Kim (packet item)

About: Michael Kim (case)

Page 2 · file page 2014 larger image
Image of page 2; its text is alongside
Text: digital text layer
Interview of Mel Fonthal 
April 16, 2025 
Page 2  
 
 
 
The mission of the California Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training is to continually enhance  
the professionalism of California law enforcement in serving its communities.  
 
 
Comments between Fonthal and Wan wee conversations, like about the open 
sexual harassment case. 
 
Kim applied in 2021.  Fonthal did not think the application went anywhere.  At that 
time, BIU had more discretion what applications to work.  Fonthal was unaware who 
determined not to work the application as a background investigation file.  Now, there was 
a decision that every single applicant gets worked, no matter what.  Fonthal never heard 
that the 2021 file was not worked because someone said they could not hire Kim. . . .you 
cannot tell someone that. 
 
Shown an email dated November 30, 2023, from Fonthal to Kim, Fonthal stated it 
was a non-select letter.  He was unaware what the sent emails looked like that Guardian 
generated based on his input into the system.  When someone goes through the chain of 
command (ladder), at the end, if the Sheriff says “no,” that’s a non-select.  That’s the only 
non-select that they have.  Everyone else is a disqualified. 
 
Dr. Nucci did the first psychological evaluation of Kim.  If there is a not suitable 
evaluation, Fonthal sends an official letter which details the conclusion of disqualification 
and the appeals process.  The applicant has a chance to appeal and, if so, Fonthal sends 
another letter saying the appeal is received and says to the applicant to get an official 
doctor’s evaluation.  Fonthal sends a list of POST-approved doctors to the applicant. 
 
Kim selected Dr. Dunnigan.  Fonthal then sends Dunnigan’s name to LEPS for 
review of whether Dunnigan is certified.  After Dunnigan, it would go to a third – HR – 
doctor for final say on suitability. 
 
Kim failed his first psychological evaluation because of the sexual harassment case.  
Kim told BIU that the complainant was a female who was against him and her allegations 
were not true.  That investigation came back as not sustained, so Kim went back to 
Dunnigan and told him about the investigation’s conclusion.  Dunnigan did a re-evaluation 
and said Kim was suitable.  Then, it went to a third doctor. 
 
In BIU, there was internal discussion about Kim appealing Dunnigan’s initial decision 
of not suitable.  Fonthal was told to “pause” the background investigation and told to wait 
until after the sexual harassment investigation concluded.  Sheriff Paul Miyamoto called 
Fonthal’s office.  Fonthal and Martindale share the same office. Usually, they spoke on 
speakerphone.  It could have been over speakerphone.  Miyamoto said to please continue 
the file.  Miyamoto did not say anything about Kim possibly reaching out to him.  The phone 
call occurred right after the not suitable finding came back (or in the same time period).  
Fonthal or Martindale would have told the Sheriff about the not suitable finding.  Or, Fonthal 
told his captain and she forwarded it. 
It’s not a normal occurrence for Fonthal or Martindale to brief Miyamoto directly but it 
has happened.  There was not an order to give updates to Miyamoto about Kim’s 
background investigation but there was an “understanding” because Kim was one of them 
before and he’s a “special case.”  When people leave SFSO, BIU gives command staff a 
2014

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.