POSAAB Meeting Transcript - April 15, 2026
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- board hearing transcript (kind from doc_type)
- File
- 3d22a29abc7880edc84700e15513c91c7d967381 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Julio Quintanilla (case)
POSAAB Meeting, April 15, 2026
1 representing both Officer Zavala and Officer Quintanilla
2 related to this POST investigation.
3 My basic statement that I would like you all to be
4 aware of is the U.S. Supreme Court case Graham v.
5 Connor, which is referenced in the materials. But it
6 specifically provides for any use of force by any law
7 enforcement officer in the country, but we're
8 specifically talking about California; that that use of
9 force is viewed through the perspective of a reasonable,
10 similarly trained officer, under the same circumstances,
11 based on the totality of the circumstances.
12 I believe in this particular case, the officers'
13 actions do not rise to the clear and convincing level.
14 LAPD's standard that they use the preponderance of the
15 evidence, which is lower than POST's.
16 Both officers expressed their fear of the imminent
17 threat that they believed this victim posed to them,
18 based on the knife and his prior actions. So that is
19 the reason that I believe POST will not be able to prove
20 it beyond clear and convincing.
21 I would also note that the Division is recommending
22 either revocation or suspension. And so if this board
23 disagrees with my vision of the laws that applies to
24 this particular case, then I would ask that you
25 recommend suspension as opposed to revocation.
65
SWANK REPORTING INC. (916) 390-7731
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.