Documents › 2fdfa6eead7bdc0f0a0b360f9a01c917fcf25ddd:9-15

Monterey Park PD Notice of Intent to Terminate - Lieutenant Frank Duke

Agency records disciplinediscipline and employment 2022-05-23 Monterey Park Police Department 7 pages (file pages 9–15) original file
About this document
Layer
agency record: part of a file an agency produced
Type as titled
notice of intent to terminate (kind from doc_type)
Produced as
monterey-park-police-department/26-19 PRA Req_Redacted.pdf
File
2fdfa6eead7bdc0f0a0b360f9a01c917fcf25ddd application/pdf
Cases
POST 2308491 · Frank Ruben Duke (record)

About: Frank Ruben Duke (case)

Page 5 · file page 13 larger image
Image of page 5; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

organizations and their success depends upon the chain of command. Police officers are always required to obey lawful orders from their superior officers. By willfully disobeying direct orders given to you (which you acknowledged receiving in writing on August 17, 2021), you have shown that you are not fit to remain employed as a peace officer for the City.

You tried to claim during your interview that you believed you were still a peace officer but just could not exercise peace officer powers. However, you asked the Chief of Police for another City to keep your conduct a secret by saying multiple times that he “did not see you.” You therefore knew you were deliberately disobeying orders by representing yourself as a peace officer at the ceremony. There is no other explanation for your statements to Chief Harris. By repeatedly asking another law enforcement officer to conceal your conduct, you demonstrated a severe lack of integrity.

During your interview, you denied knowing that you were violating my orders by wearing your uniform to the ceremony. However, your comments to Chief Harris reveal you were fully aware. In addition, you admitted during your interview, “I knew it would make an issue if I was there in uniform with this chief.” I therefore find that you were dishonest during your administrative interview when you denied knowing you were violating orders. A police officer is expected to tell the truth at all times, and credibility and honesty are essential traits of a law enforcement professional. (See, Ackerman v. State Personnel Bd. (1983) 145 Cal.App.3d 395, 400.) Conversely, dishonesty is an intolerable flaw in a law enforcement officer. (See, Kolender v. San Diego County Civil Service Com. (2005) 132 Cal.App.4th 716, 721.) By being dishonest, you violated section 319.5.9, subdivision (h) of the Department’s Policy Manual, and you also demonstrated that you have a trait that is incompatible with being a peace officer.

When a peace officer dons a uniform and badge, the public believes they are a law enforcement officer and can trust them as such. This is a very important role in society and one which should never be abused. Chief Harris was understandably concerned as to why you were showing him that you had empty magazines while you were wearing a uniform with a badge. Your conduct brought dishonor and disgrace to both yourself and this Department, in violation of Department Policy Manual section 336.5. When someone with your experience knowingly violates laws, regulations and orders like you did, I cannot trust that person to adhere to law, regulations, or orders in other circumstances in the future. You knew what you were doing: you went out of your way to call Chief Harris’s attention to what you were doing and to point out that you were not carrying bullets. You knew it was improper but you still did it because wearing your uniform and giving the appearance that you were a peace officer was important to you in that moment. In fact, when asked by Captain Kim why you wore the police uniform while your powers were suspended, you responded, “For my son’s graduation. I’ve waited 25 years for this,” as if the significance of the event was more important than obeying orders. I cannot trust that if you were faced with another set of circumstances that required you to choose between your own self-interests and the Department’s best interests, that you would not put your interests over the Department’s again.

With the principles set forth in Skelly in mind, I am proposing termination of your employment as a Lieutenant. Given both your insubordination and efforts to conceal your misconduct, I can no longer trust your integrity.

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.