Documents › 2fdfa6eead7bdc0f0a0b360f9a01c917fcf25ddd:9-15

Monterey Park PD Notice of Intent to Terminate - Lieutenant Frank Duke

Agency records disciplinediscipline and employment 2022-05-23 Monterey Park Police Department 7 pages (file pages 9–15) original file
About this document
Layer
agency record: part of a file an agency produced
Type as titled
notice of intent to terminate (kind from doc_type)
Produced as
monterey-park-police-department/26-19 PRA Req_Redacted.pdf
File
2fdfa6eead7bdc0f0a0b360f9a01c917fcf25ddd application/pdf
Cases
POST 2308491 · Frank Ruben Duke (record)

About: Frank Ruben Duke (case)

Page 4 · file page 12 larger image
Image of page 4; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

with Monterey Park Police patches, a badge, a Sam Browne belt, and a holster with a handgun at a police academy graduation in Rancho Cucamonga. Your son was one of the graduates.

At the graduation, you saw the Chief Gene Harris of the San Gabriel Police Department. You said to Chief Harris, "you didn't see me." Chief Harris responded, "ok, I didn't see you." Chief Harris was not sure what you were talking about and assumed you were just joking.

During the ceremony, you stood on stage with Chief Kling of the Rialto Police Department. You were announced as "Lieutenant Frank Duke from the Monterey Park Police Department." When your son was called, you handed him a piece of paper and hugged him, donning a Monterey Park police uniform with Monterey Park patches, detective badge, Sam Browne belt, and an unloaded handgun.

After the graduation, you walked up to Chief Harris and again stated, "you didn't see me." Chief Harris replied, "I don't know...I guess not...I didn't see you." You then opened your ammunition magazine pouch and pulled out two empty handgun magazines. You said, "I don't have any bullets so I'm good."

Chief Harris realized that something was wrong. He was concerned that a police officer would be in uniform without any bullets in their magazine. Chief Harris called me and notified me of what had occurred. I assigned Captain Eric Kim to conduct an investigation.

When interviewed during the investigation, you were asked, "Did you know that it's a violation of this [August 17, 2021] memo that was given to you to wear a uniform while you're on administrative leave?" You responded "No."

V. ANALYSIS

In Skelly v. State Personnel Bd. (1975) 15 Cal.3d 194, the California Supreme Court stated that the "overriding consideration" when addressing whether a public employer has imposed an appropriate level of discipline is "the extent to which the employee's conduct resulted in, or if repeated is likely to result in, 'harm to the public service.'" (Id. at 218.) "Other relevant factors include the circumstances surrounding the misconduct and the likelihood of its recurrence." (Id.) With these principles in mind, I believe there is sufficient evidence supporting the proposal to terminate you from employment.

As you know, your peace officer powers were suspended on August 17, 2021 due to concerns that you were not fit for duty. Instead of abiding by the explicit orders given to you, you chose to represent yourself as a law enforcement officer, donning a uniform, badge, Sam Browne belt, and holster with a handgun. You appeared on stage and were held out as "Lieutenant Frank Duke from the Monterey Park Police Department." Your conduct constituted a misdemeanor under California Penal Code section 538d, subdivision (a), because you represented yourself as a peace officer while your powers were suspended. In doing so, you also violated section 319.4 of the Department's Policy Manual, which requires that you abide by the law. You additionally violated section 319.5.1(b) of the Department's Policy Manual by deliberately disobeying my August 17, 2021 orders, and section 211.2 by not requesting my permission to attend the ceremony as a representative of this Department. Police departments are paramilitary

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.