POST Report of Interview of Mel Fonthal
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- interview transcript (kind from doc_type)
- File
- 17822b66f2c0343bf30f00634f6ecc3cc7d78812 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Michael Kim (case)
Interview of Mel Fonthal
April 16, 2025
Page 3
heads up on progress in the background investigations. Miyamoto has called BIU about other applicants.
There were obvious concerns about Kim's conviction.
Asked how often have you seen successful in overturning a "not suitable," Fonthal stated 1 in 10. Asked how often an applicant's own doctor provides a "suitable" finding, Fonthal stated 9 in 10. Fonthal has never seen an appeal of an appeal – or an applicant's own doctor making a finding of "not suitable" and the applicant appealing that decision.
Shown a letter addressed "To Whom It May Concern," Fonthal stated that the letter was attached to a report submitted by Dunnigan. Dunnigan said he received the letter. Fonthal did not talk to Dunnigan about the letter. He is not aware anyone talked to Dunnigan about the letter. Fonthal did not talk to Miyamoto about the letter. Fonthal has not seen Miyamoto write a letter on behalf of anyone else. Fonthal did not consider that Kim wrote the letter. Fonthal agreed the letter was not signed, not on letterhead, and undated.
The talk in BIU about the letter was "that's a first!" BIU did not question a doctor's conclusions. Fonthal has never seen a letter of recommendation attached to a psychologist's evaluation report.
Fonthal did not tell Kim to reach out to Dunnigan to appeal. It's possible Miyamoto or Martindale told Kim to do that. There was no official direction from anyone at SFSO that Fonthal is aware of to provide Kim guidance to appeal Dunnigan's evaluation. There is nothing against a second appeal. It's the third doctor's opinion that counts, so no matter what the second doctor says does not matter.
Asked about language in the letter about people at SFSO were comfortable with Kim returning to work as a deputy, Fonthal said that was not the official BIU position. BIU did not have an opinion. Fonthal is unsure who told Kim SFSO wanted him to return. Kim has lots of friends at SFSO, so maybe someone told him that. Fonthal can only assume that others would not speak officially on behalf of SFSO to say they were comfortable with Kim returning. It's possible that Kim was referring to the letter when he told Dunnigan that SFSO was comfortable. It's possible the Undersheriff or an Assistant Sheriff told Kim that they were comfortable with him returning.
Ladder is a term used in Guardian or SFSO for the approval process. Pages 373-74 and page 375 have a ladder. They look different to Fonthal, although they appear both to show the same result. When the ladder says that Martindale "approved" the file, it meant that the file was ready to be looked at. The ladder process includes emails sent to the chain of command and they sit at their desks and vote. The only person who matters in the ladder is the Sheriff.
Fonthal had not heard about any memorandum Kim wrote and gave to Matt Freeman.
The mission of the California Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training is to continually enhance the professionalism of California law enforcement in serving its communities.
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.