434 - BR3_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Redacted_Attachment_B.pdf
About this document
- Layer
- packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
- Type as titled
- case_attachment (kind from hand)
- File
- 0b59e47e939063f8938332267911cbb97f962b8a application/pdf
- Cases
About: James Mutuku (case)
said, "He feels like somehow, he's in charge. Somewhere in his head, he thinks he is part of the supervision."
I told Smith Officer 4 moved Complainant to Area 5 during a roll call in September and asked if he was present. Smith did not recall Complainant being moved to Area 5. He said he may have been gone and thought he would have heard about that. I asked if he had been present if he would have found that unusual. Smith answered, "No, because people move around all the time." He had senior officers on graveyard that they had to move and when he was on swing shift, he had to move Officer Phil Sears, who is a fifteen-year plus officer. Smith liked Sears, but in order to keep Smith's squad together, there were a couple times Smith would "bump" him. Sears like to work east but was assigned to north or vice versa. Smith told him sorry, but explained he wanted to keep his squad together under his supervision. Smith heard Sears had an issue with it because he was a senior officer. Smith totally understood, but he spoke to Sears about it. He said, "Actually Compt. came to me about that one as well." Smith explained he had just started with his squad, needed to see them, he liked to ride with them, be in the same beat with them, and Sears was the odd man out. Smith moved Sears for a couple weeks in a row, until they were able to dial in where everyone would work.
I asked if it would be unusual to move a senior officer into a beat they were not assigned to work. Smith said it wasn't common and you usually asked for volunteers. However, if it was on the senior side of the week and there were shortages, it would be the senior officer that would be moved. Smith wasn't there, so he couldn't say why Complainant was moved. Senior officers had "pull" and supervisors tried to accommodate them. If it was the senior end of the week, all officers were senior, but Complainant was probably the most senior. Smith said it was uncommon to move a senior officer, but not unheard of. Supervisors tried to keep senior officers in their assigned beats or allow them to work a different beat if they chose, however there could be occasions when a senior officer was moved out of their beat for a number of reasons. For example, Smith was south, but on his Monday, he came in when a senior crew was south. In this case, Smith and his entire crew were "bumped" to east. Then Officer 3 crew came in, but only Complainant and Weddle from the crew would go east and Officer 3 would take them. Smith wanted to keep his crew together, so he would move Sears. He reiterated it was not unheard of for senior officers to be moved, whether they liked it or not, even though supervisors did try to accommodate them.
I confirmed Smith's crew was assigned west on the south end of the city, but regularly worked east, because there was a senior crew (a sergeant senior to Smith) that worked west on Smith's and his crew's Monday. Smith said yes, west was taken by Tipre's crew and Smith ended up being a "floater" and was spread out. Kouroubacalis, Officer 1 and Officer 2 would work together in east even though Smith would have to bounce around. He added swing shift was kind of a mess because you had sergeants moving around and a lot of seniority. He said Kouroubacalis was a twenty-year officer and she "bounced around every single shift." She worked every beat in the city. She understood they needed to move people and she was fine with moving.
Smith has worked with Officer 4 a long time. Officer 4 was "absolutely" professional and Smith thought he did what was best for the watch, to include where he placed people on the roster.
Administrative Investigation: PC2211047 / Hostile Work Environment Claim
Page 61 of 155
315
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.