434 - BR3_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Redacted_Attachment_B.pdf
About this document
- Layer
- packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
- Type as titled
- case_attachment (kind from hand)
- File
- 0b59e47e939063f8938332267911cbb97f962b8a application/pdf
- Cases
About: James Mutuku (case)
Smith let him know that while he supervised them, nothing was going to change. It was Smith's decision, it was approved by Officer 4 and it was best for the Department.
They also talked about staffing shortages, but not once were they understaffed. They may have had backfills or holdovers, but they had the officers required for the shift. They also met the staffing for Watch C which is twenty officers.
The first conversation took place in the sergeant's bay and Officer 3 was there. Smith did not know if anyone else was in the bay. Officer 3 supported Smith's decision but didn't say anything while Complainant was present.
I asked Smith what he meant by typical "Complainant fashion. Smith did not believe Complainant had respect for the rank and most of the people in it. He said, "You almost just waive it off, because his opinion doesn't matter." Smith has always tried to support Complainant to the best of his ability but did not agree with Complainant opinions because they were usually too far off to take seriously. Complainant brought Smith his concerns; Smith listened and talked to him about policy, law, and troop welfare, and told him it was going to continue whether he liked it or not. They agreed to disagree, and it was cordial. Complainant did not yell at Smith and tell him he was an unfit supervisor like he has done before.
Complainant worked for Officer 3 but Smith worked with Complainant two or three days per week.
Complainant was the only officer to complain about Officer 1 and Officer 2. He said Weddle, who rode with Complainant at the time, never complained to him either and Smith and Weddle were on SWAT together. Smith and Weddle had candid conversations all the time related to patrol and SWAT, and he never mentioned a concern about Officer 1 and Officer 2 riding together.
Smith did not know if Weddle didn't say anything because he truly did not have an issue or he learned Complainant had gone to Smith and Smith told him nothing was going to change. Smith did not know, but said Weddle knew if Smith made a decision, Weddle wouldn't likely change it.
Smith was not aware of any issues Complainant had with Officer 1 and Officer 2. Smith heard rumors Complainant felt he had been split from riding as a two-officer unit, because Officer 1 and Officer 2 were getting pushed to ride together. Smith said he would have done this too (split Complainant a lot earlier, because Officer 1 and Officer 2 were more productive as a two-person unit than Complainant was in Smith's opinion. Officer 1 and Officer 2 were definitely higher in stats and calls for service; they were the leaders. Smith thought there was just something there, a "distaste" Complainant had for them; a belief "they weren't good enough." Smith couldn't put his finger on it, but believed it was personal. He described it as some "negativity" between Complainant and Officer 2 riding together. I asked if it was possible Complainant was jealous. Smith answered, "Jealous (in the affirmative) and I mean you gotta [sic] remember that Complainant thinks everyone's under him." He added, "Complainant thinks everyone has to answer to him." This included sergeants, where everyone went, parked, what beats they were assigned. Smith
Administrative Investigation: PC2211047 / Hostile Work Environment Claim
Page 60 of 155
314
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.