Documents › 08aacc9b28e2b96616efca444250d5eae909b5eb:304-331

736 - BR05_POST2311370_Zavala Jose_Attachment D - COP IntradeptMemo_Redacted.pdf

POST board correspondencecorrespondence and logs 2026-04-15 28 pages (file pages 304–331) original file
About this document
Layer
packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
Type as titled
case_attachment (kind from title)
File
08aacc9b28e2b96616efca444250d5eae909b5eb application/pdf
Cases
POST 2311370 · Jose Zavala (packet item)

About: Jose Zavala (case)

Page 12 · file page 315 larger image
Image of page 12; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

The Honorable Board of Police Commissioners

Page 12

3.2

As the only supervisor at the scene, Sergeant was forced to simultaneously perform multiple tasks. While he could have delegated some of his tasks, such as acquiring the ballistic shield, and he could have refrained from communicating with Victim once additional units arrived, the Majority opined that Sergeant was able to oversee and direct the officers at the scene without compromising his supervisory oversight.

As it pertains to Sergeant's direction to Officer 1 to discharge his first impact round, the Majority noted that Victim had stood up while holding the knife to his throat and made the sign of the crucifix leading Sergeant to believe he may attempt suicide by cop or run toward his family. The Majority also noted that Sergeant was concerned Victim may harm civilians. Per Sergeant, there were crowds of people on Street 2 west and east of the apartment building, as well as an individual who almost exited the building behind Victim. According to Sergeant, the comments of the radio call had indicated that Victim was chasing people down the street and Sergeant believed "one-hundred percent" that Victim was a threat to the community. Sergeant hoped that officers could use the 40mm LLL to bring the situation to an end. The Board also noted that before directing Officer 1 to discharge the 40mm LLL, he announced "Forty stand by!" to alert officers that less lethal was being used and to prevent the contagious use of lethal force. Sergeant then directed Officer 1 to discharge the 40mm LLL, stating, "Hit 'em!" Based on his articulation, the Majority opined that Sergeant reasonably believed that Victim posed an immediate threat to the safety of others.

Sergeant recalled,

"That's the point where I directed Officer 1 to discharge the 40 at him. Reason why I did that was due to the fact that my concern was that at this point he may possibly take off running and go and start, you know, attacking civilians. I was hoping it would end with the one shot to the 40.13

Again, based off the comments of the call, he's already chased people down the street with a knife. I believed that he was going to attempt to do something like that again. I wanted to stop it before it happened. My concern was for the community out there. I didn't want this guy to start hacking at -- hacking away at people.14

It hit him. It didn't seem like it phased him. He walked down a few more stairs and then he sat. And at that point I was -- I was good with that, because I think, I believed that that made him change his mind from going to run. He hit it. He felt it. Now he sat down, and I think, you know, it gave us some time for him to, you know, maybe in his mind evaluate what was going on. So, I believed that was successful in that aspect, because he didn't take off running, trying to hurt anybody.15


13 Sergeant's transcript, Page 12, Lines 2-8.

14 Sergeant's transcript, Page 29, Lines 11-17.

15 Sergeant's transcript, Pages 29-30, Lines 21-6.

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.