Documents › 06860f743b94373df18c8fa0889eae4e2eb0d75a:1-14

Daly City Police Department Administrative Interview Transcript 24-07 (Kevin Smithmatungol)

POST board interview transcriptagency investigation 2025-01-31 14 pages (file pages 1–14) original file
About this document
Layer
attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
Type as titled
ia interview transcript (kind from doc_type)
File
06860f743b94373df18c8fa0889eae4e2eb0d75a application/pdf
Cases
POST 2505112 · Kevin Smithmatungol (filed under case)

About: Kevin Smithmatungol (case)

Page 12 · file page 12 larger image
Image of page 12; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

DCPD Administrative Interview

1
2 Smithmatungol I don't, I don't know when I wrote these, I don't know why I wrote these. I, I just don't.

3
4 Ciucci Okay. Um, and it's difficult for me on my end to, to, to understand it. It is, it, it truly is. I'm not
5 gonna give you any baloney. I, I have a difficulty understanding how, uh, a date and a time and a
6 remark could be on there, um, if it wasn't what occurred. Um, and so I, stopping this interview or
7 ending it, um, kind of having that as like the lingering last, uh, um, clarification or words on it is
8 troublesome to me. It, it truly, it truly is. Um, because then at that point I'm left to compile the evidence
9 and when we're looking at the, the findings and recommendations, it becomes, I have a document
10 that has a date, time and remarks. I have an officer who initially said, yeah, of course unequivocal. I
11 would be there. I I did it, I did it. And then now is at a point of, I don't remember. And so that, that kind
12 of timeline, that transition across, it troubles me. It truly does. And so I, I ask, is there anything that
13 you can, uh, provide me without specific questioning, uh, without specific yes, no's back and forth,
14 that can help, uh, add circumstance, context, or understanding of why those would be written as they
15 are, but why they wouldn't be supported with any factual evidence?

16
17 Smithmatungol I, I, I don't, I, I'm trying to think of something, but I dunno why I would put no answer if
18 I didn't serve 'em. I really don't.

19
20 Ciucci Okay. Have you ever gotten in trouble for not serving a subpoena before, either formally or
21 informally? Informal meaning your sergeant just goes, hey, what are you doing and, and has a, a little
22 talk to you about it. Have you ever had, uh, anything like that in your career?

23
24 Smithmatungol To my knowledge, no. I've never gotten in trouble for a subpoena.

25
26 Ciucci Okay. Do you recall ever being in trouble for a subpoena? Kind of a more of a yes or no?
27 Yeah, I think you would know. I, i I like to hope you would know if you were in trouble for a subpoena
28 previously.

29
30 Smithmatungol Maybe putting, not served.

31
32 Ciucci Okay. That's an understandable thing. 'cause you said that was something that got brought up,
33 not served. Um--

34
35 Fox Anything in addition to that?

36
37 Smithmatungol No, I've never was confronted about serving subpoenas. I I've never been any of that
38 sort.

39
40 Ciucci Do you have any reason to, uh, misrepresent fact, in order to avoid punishment or avoid
41 confrontation with supervisors, is there anything that would cause you whether the intent is a, a, an
42 honorable one or not, that would cause you to go ahead and, and say that you serve something or
43 you attempted to, even if you didn't, do you have a reason to avoid consequence?

44
45 Smithmatungol No, because I've never gotten a consequence for not serving subpoena. I, I, I don't
46 know what a punishment would be, but I thinking about this, I remember these dates, how the time, I
47 don't, I dunno why. I really don't.

48
49 Ciucci Okay. Um, I'm also not just gonna hold you in here <laugh> and, and just keep asking kind of
50 the same question 30 different times, 30 different ways. Yeah. I just want to make sure that when
51 you're walking out, you have been, you feel that you have had every opportunity that you have in
52 order to add clarity to this. And I feel comfortable that I've asked every question I can in order to get
53 that clarity. But I'm goin to be very frank with you when I say I don't have clarity on this. I don't have
54 clarity on this issue. And my understanding of this interview is that there's a date and time on two
55 subpoenas and a remark that says no answer when fundamentally I have, uh, um, supporting
56 evidence that shows it didn't occur. And so that for me is troublesome. Um, but I wanna make sure
57 that when we're walking out that you have had every opportunity that you feel deservedly to state your
58 case and, and make it clear to me. But I'm being honest, I don't understand it.

59
60 Fox That there's nothing left unsaid.

12

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.