Law Office of Todd Simonson Investigative Report IA 22-07 (Officer Paul Matejcek)
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- ia investigative report (kind from doc_type)
- File
- 03d5ce0e699e63498d4b82aafa8515c9d8b860b7 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Paul Matejcek (case)
would be appropriate under those circumstances, from what I recall at the time of that incident.
Asked whether he was taught during defensive tactics training at the San Mateo Sheriff's Department or at Brentwood that there were situations in which a suspect could be kicked, Officer Franson stated:
I mean, I don't remember specifically talking about kicking a suspect in that situation. However, the way that continuum of force goes, I mean, for example, lethal force doesn't have to be from a firearm, it doesn't have to be from a vehicle or blade, it can be anything, but that's if that situation requires that or reaches that level, and this, no.
Asked whether Ms. [V1] actions rose to the level he had just described, Officer Franson stated, "No, unless I completely missed something, I don't think I did though." Officer Franson stated that he was not aware of any prior negative interactions between Officer Matejcek and Ms. [V1] that would have prompted Officer Matejcek to kick her. Officer Franson stated that after the incident, he and Officer Flynn spoke with Officer Matejcek while Ms. [V1] was in the back of the patrol car and told him that they did not agree with his use of force and that they would need to discuss it with the Sergeant. Officer Franson stated that Officer Matejcek became "defensive" and was "taking offense" to this criticism and said that "he felt her standing up was presenting some sort of threat to him." Officer Franson stated, "the way he spoke about it was almost like it was a justifiable use of force, and I did not agree with that. Never saw that and still don't."
Officer Franson said that he discussed the incident with Officer Flynn at the scene while Officer Matejcek was off somewhere else, perhaps at the front of the Home Depot building. Officer Franson stated, "I think we both briefly discussed it and we were shocked. We were just completely like, 'Where did that come from? What just happened?' So we were just trying to process it and we were like, 'Hey, did you see what I saw?' 'Yes.' 'Okay, so we're on the same page, why did that happen?' And we were both baffled by it." Officer Franson stated that he had never seen Officer Matejcek do anything like that before.
Officer Franson stated that after the incident he believed that Ms. [V1] must have complained about the kick because "I think that's what prompted me to suggest that we call for medical attention, was just in case there was something related to that [kick]." Officer Franson recalled that AMR was only on the scene briefly and after examining Ms. [V1] the EMTs determined that she did not require medical treatment.
Officer Franson stated that when he returned to the Department, Officer Matejcek and Officer Flynn were standing at the sallyport with Sergeant Alvarez. Officer Franson stated that they explained to Sergeant Alvarez "in essence, that this was the situation we came upon, what we were dispatched to, which I believe he was already aware of that we contacted [V1] at the shed. She was cuffed, she got mouthy, she stood up, Officer Matejcek kicked her. I don't remember verbatim what was said, but I think it was conveyed to him [Sergeant Alvarez] that it was a use of force and it may not have been a justifiable use of force." Officer Franson stated
Confidential Report
City of Brentwood
10
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.