Law Office of Todd Simonson Investigative Report IA 22-07 (Officer Paul Matejcek)
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- ia investigative report (kind from doc_type)
- File
- 03d5ce0e699e63498d4b82aafa8515c9d8b860b7 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Paul Matejcek (case)
discussed was alcohol influence. I do remember smelling a strong odor of an alcoholic beverage coming from her person, her eyes were red and watery. I believe there was alcohol influence. I don't know at that point, I believe there was drug influence."
Officer Franson stated that he felt like Ms. [V1] "was maintaining a certain level of calm, and then I feel like all of the sudden it kind of ramped up and I'm not sure why that happened." The Investigator played footage from 6:44 minute mark to the 7:58 minute mark in which Ms. [V1] tells Officer Matejcek to stop following her and says, "I don't give a fuck if it's beer or not, drink as much beer as I fucking want." Officer Franson stated at that point he was just standing off to the side waiting for Officer Matejcek to figure out a disposition for the call, "and I would think in the forefront of his mind would be alcohol influence, drug influence, trespassing, something like that, maybe even vandalism."
Asked why he muted the audio on his camera (at the 8:10 minute mark) in the video footage, Officer Franson stated, "I'm assuming, I can't tell you for sure if there was something I was about to say, I think just game planning is why, and there being no need to record what we were going to discuss, but I don't know for sure what we said at that point." Officer Franson stated that in watching the video leading up to the kick, he could not recall exactly what was being discussed, but he recalled that Ms. [V1] got upset and began moving her body and tucking her legs in preparation to stand up while Officer Matejcek and Officer Flynn ordered her to remain seated. Officer Franson estimated that at this point he, Officer Flynn, and Officer Matejcek were all standing about seven to eight feet away from Ms. [V1]. Officer Franson agreed that starting at the 8:58 minute mark, the video appeared to show Officer Matejcek take two or three quick steps toward Ms. [V1] and then kick her in the left torso area with his right foot causing Ms. [V1] to fall backwards.
Officer Franson stated that he did not know why Officer Matejcek kicked Ms. [V1], and that he had "no idea" ahead of time that Officer Matejcek was going to do that. Asked if he was surprised by the kick, Officer Franson stated, "Absolutely. I'm still surprised." Asked why he and Officer Flynn were standing still when Officer Matejcek initiated the kick, Officer Franson stated that was because "I did not fear a threat near that level at that point at all." Officer Franson agreed that there were other options involving less force such as pulling Ms. [V1] back into a seated position by her arms or escorting her to be detained in a vehicle. Officer Franson stated that he did not believe that Officer Matejcek's kick was a reasonable use of force under the circumstances. Asked to explain why it was not reasonable, Officer Franson stated:
Well, first off she's handcuffed. She's a fairly small person, that's comparing her to me. Officer Matejcek's size is different than mine,2 it's different than Flynn's, he's smaller than both of us as far as height . . . Yeah, so comparing size, the fact she's handcuffed, I believe that she had been pat searched at that point, so there's no concern. I mean, maybe biting, but she wasn't showing us that as an indicator that she might bite us, or spitting, there was none of that going on. It was clearly just way too far, as far as force goes, for that. Like you said, grabbing an arm, verbal commands to light touch, to maybe a control hold,
2 Officer Franson previously stated his height is [PII] and his weight is [PII]
Confidential Report
City of Brentwood
9
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.