Documents › f51ea272f004c1b7ce4d05d07e798d2731fbebc3:3-26

State Personnel Board Proposed Decision Richard Adams v. Department of California Highway Patrol (Case No. 24-1576)

POST board commission decisionboard proceeding 2025-04-15 24 pages (file pages 3–26) original file
About this document
Layer
attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
Type as titled
administrative law judge decision (kind from doc_type)
File
f51ea272f004c1b7ce4d05d07e798d2731fbebc3 application/pdf
Cases
POST 2403212 · Richard Adams (filed under case)

About: Richard Adams (case)

Page 18 · file page 20 larger image
Image of page 18; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

Richard Adams
Case No. 24-1576
Page 18 of 24

Several unidentified coworkers referred to Appellant's military leave as "military vacation," which he found to be derogatory. Assuming for the sake of analysis that those comments were meant to be derogatory, the evidence established neither who made the comments nor whether they played any role in the decision to dismiss Appellant. Lieutenant Lee was aware of Appellant's use of military leave, but no evidence suggested that he had any role in the decision to dismiss Appellant.

Sergeant Mason heard a coworker or coworkers describe Appellant as a "military guy" to refer to his general demeanor, and was aware that Appellant had some type of military background. However, the evidence did not establish that Sergeant Mason knew that Appellant took military leave to serve as a reservist Marine. Moreover, although Sergeant Mason drafted the NOAA, he did not participate in the decision to dismiss Appellant. No evidence suggested that Appellant's military service had any bearing on Sergeant Mason's investigation.

Appellant did not prove that Respondent's decision to dismiss him was motivated by retaliation for his service as a reservist Marine, or otherwise prove that Appellant's dismissal violated the USERRA. Therefore, Appellant's affirmative defense is rejected.

Inexcusable Neglect of Duty

Finding inexcusable neglect of duty requires finding that an employee intentionally or with gross negligence failed to exercise due diligence in the performance of a known official duty. (U.W. (1993) SPB Dec. No. 93-10.) To be subject to discipline for inexcusable neglect of duty, an employee must have actual or constructive notice of expected standards of conduct, unless the conduct is so clearly wrong that notice is not necessary. (E.D. (1993) SPB Dec. No. 93-32.) Because peace officers must be above

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.