State Personnel Board Proposed Decision Richard Adams v. Department of California Highway Patrol (Case No. 24-1576)
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- administrative law judge decision (kind from doc_type)
- File
- f51ea272f004c1b7ce4d05d07e798d2731fbebc3 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Richard Adams (case)
Richard Adams
Case No. 24-1576
Page 15 of 24
Appellant several times to stop. Appellant's testimony therefore was not consistent with the video footage.
Victim was not present at the hearing and did not testify. However, Appellant's statements about the consensual nature of the incident were inconsistent with Victim's statements to the SDSD. Although Victim later wrote that she was not abused by Appellant, and told Deputy Perez that Appellant had never harmed her, it is unfortunately common for domestic violence victims to later recant their statements, even if true. Also, Victim's statement that she was drunk during the Poway incident was contradicted by Deputy Powroznik's and Deputy McKemy's testimony.
Appellant testified in a calm manner, and his testimony generally was consistent with his statements to Sergeant Mason. At times, however, Appellant appeared to be evasive and attempted to downplay his conduct. He also tried to volunteer information beyond the question asked at times. No other witness testified that Appellant and Victim engaged in consensual role-playing, and there was no evidence that Victim made any statement to that effect.
Appellant, who was trained to identify signs of alcoholic intoxication, testified that Victim was intoxicated when she spoke to the SDSD deputies. However, Appellant's testimony conflicted with the testimonies of both Deputy Powroznik and Deputy McKemy, who also were both trained to identify signs of intoxication. Deputy Powroznik and Deputy McKemy both testified that they stood within a few feet of Victim and did not smell alcohol or observe any other signs of intoxication. Both deputies testified in a direct, clear, consistent, and unexaggerated manner, and neither had any apparent interest in the outcome of the hearing.
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.