Documents › ee696953db12e1c0c5af96076eb141052b5a3d43:1-26

POST Investigative Summary and Findings - Paul Matejcek (POST2300017)

POST board investigative summaryboard proceeding 2024-08-23 26 pages (file pages 1–26) original file
About this document
Layer
attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
Type as titled
investigative summary and findings (kind from doc_type)
File
ee696953db12e1c0c5af96076eb141052b5a3d43 application/pdf
Cases
POST 2300017 · Paul Matejcek (filed under case)

About: Paul Matejcek (case)

Page 7 · file page 7 larger image
Image of page 7; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

In the Notice of Intent to Terminate, dated August 15, 2022, from Chief Thomas Hansen to Respondent, Chief Hansen stated that Respondent's use of force warranted termination because it was "an egregious use of excessive force."16 Chief Hansen further stated the Contra Costa County District Attorney was evaluating criminal charges but the filing of criminal charges would not impact the imposition of discipline as the District Attorney uses a different standard of proof.17 On September 15, 2022, the District Attorney declined to file charges because of insufficient evidence. Following a Skelly hearing, Chief Hansen served Respondent with a Notice of Termination, dated August 31, 2022.18 As stated in the Notice of Termination, Chief Hansen considered – and rejected – Respondent's and Respondent's counsel's arguments that the use of force was justified because of the threat of Victim 1 spitting or fighting. Chief Hansen stated, "Nothing can justify the violent force that you used under the circumstances. You were not faced with imminent danger and the need to make a split-second decision. You employed what can be fairly described as bully tactics."19

On September 2, 2022, Matejcek appealed the termination pursuant to Brentwood Police Department Policy Manual, Policy 1028.20 On December 12, 2023, Paul D. Roose, the hearing officer, issued a Hearing Officer Recommendation Pursuant to Department Policy Manual ("Hearing Officer's Recommendation").21 At the hearing, the hearing officer heard testimony, including testimony from a subject matter expert offered by Matejcek, and a Brentwood Police Department sergeant who led the department's defensive tactics program and provided training to department officers. The hearing officer found that the preponderance of the evidence substantiated that Respondent "engaged in an unauthorized use of force in violation of department policy" and the "decision to kick/push the handcuffed civilian was not reasonable."22 The hearing officer reasoned that:

  • • Respondent and his fellow officers were not in "imminent danger;"
  • • If Victim 1 spat at the officers, they could have stepped aside;

16 Attachment E (Memorandum from Police Chief Thomas Hansen to Officer Paul Matejcek, Notice of Intent to Terminate (8/15/2022) at 6).

17 Attachment E (Memorandum from Police Chief Thomas Hansen to Officer Paul Matejcek, Notice of Intent to Terminate (8/15/2022) at 5).

18 Attachment F (Memorandum from Police Chief Thomas Hansen to Officer Paul Matejcek, Notice of Termination (8/31/2022)).

19 Attachment E (Memorandum from Police Chief Thomas Hansen to Officer Paul Matejcek, Notice of Intent to Terminate (8/15/2022) at 6) (emphasis supplied).

20 Attachment G (Letter from Julia D. Fox, Rains Lucia Stern St. Phalle & Silver, to Tim Ogden, Brentwood City Manager, Appeal of Notice of Termination (9/2/2022)).

21 Under Brentwood Police Department Policy No. 1028, the recommendation of the hearing officer is advisory to the City Manager, unless the City Manager is the individual who initially imposed the discipline being appealed, in which case the recommendation is advisory to the City Council. The recommendation is not binding in any way on the City Manager (or City Council), who may either accept, modify, or reject the recommended decision.

22 Attachment C (Hearing Officer Recommendation (12/12/2023) at 16).

Investigative Summary and Findings
Paul Matejcek (Respondent)
Case Number POST2300017
Page 7 of 26

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.