Aceves Rudy Notice of Determination
About this document
- Layer
- cert order: part of a file an agency produced
- Type as titled
- notice of determination (kind from doc_type)
- Produced as
- https://post.ca.gov/Portals/0/post_docs/Certification_Actions/Module/Aceves_Rudy_Notice_of_Determination.pdf
- File
- ed8797999aa502429bcf726e7ba55a6ea76c1938 application/pdf
- Cases
About: ACEVES, RUDY JR (case)
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
GAVIN NEWSOM, Governor
ROB BONTA, Attorney General
Figure: the OCR model's description, not text on the pageSeal of the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training, featuring a star with a torch and scales of justice.The seal of the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training is a seven-pointed star. In the center of the star is a circular emblem containing a torch, a pair of scales of justice, and a shield. The words "COMMISSION ON PEACE OFFICER STANDARDS AND TRAINING" are written around the perimeter of the star.
Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training
Peace Officer Standards Accountability Division
860 Stillwater Road, Suite 100
West Sacramento, CA 95605
www.post.ca.gov
Respondent said the Victim was not making any verbal threats while they were on the ground, stating, "No, I remember he was kinda grunting or screaming."
Respondent offered senseless and irrational reasons for believing the Victim posed an immediate physical threat while his hands were in his pockets:
- • Respondent did not remember where the Victim's hands were, but stated, "to me it doesn't matter where the person has their hands, they can have their hands anywhere, they are capable of assaulting you no matter where their hands are."
- • Respondent said the Victim was exhibiting pre-assaultive behavior, "tensing his body and his facial expression, he was grinding his teeth." Video evidence does not support this.
- • Respondent said additional pre-assaultive behavior was the Victim turning towards him off the wall, but video shows the Victim never fully turned to face the Respondent and turned his head farther toward him to respond when Respondent asked the Victim to repeat what he said.
- • Respondent said he did not call for assistance because there was no time due to the immediate threat to his life. Video evidence does not support the existence of any immediate physical threat.
- • Respondent said, "there was no telling if he had something at that given time" and that "he could have fashioned a weapon while in his cell", yet Respondent had searched the Victim prior to placing him in the cell.
- • Respondent said the Victim could have come into the facility with something hidden in his anal cavity. Although inmates have been known to smuggle contraband such as drugs in their anal cavity, it is highly unlikely such method would be used to smuggle a weapon into the jail facility. Further, the Victim was arrested on charges of public intoxication, making it unlikely he was secreting a weapon in his anal cavity prior to being arrested. Additionally, if Respondent thought the Victim could have had a weapon, Respondent could have ordered the Victim to take his hands out of his pockets and performed another pat down search of the Victim. Punching the Victim while his hands were still in his pockets was unreasonable under the circumstances.
- • Respondent said he had to take the Victim to the ground to keep him from opening and running out of a door, but the investigation showed that the doors in the area were locked and controlled by a Jail Deputy in the Control Room. Respondent replied that sometimes Control Room Deputies unlock the doors by accident, and sometimes the doors don't close all the way, so they are unlocked. On their face, these statements seem to be an attempt to rationalize Respondent's behavior.
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.