Documents › ec35e85f231340756593804165b762377b207641:1-4

Australian Commission for Law Enforcement Integrity Factsheet: Corruption Prevention Concepts - Conflicts of Interest

POST board evidence logevidence 4 pages (file pages 1–4) original file
About this document
Layer
attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
Type as titled
publication exhibit (kind from doc_type)
File
ec35e85f231340756593804165b762377b207641 application/pdf
Cases
POST 2300204 · David Wesley Hubbard (filed under case)

About: David Wesley Hubbard (case)

Page 2 · file page 2 larger image
Image of page 2; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

enforcement skills, knowledge, experience and access to information and methodologies may be at particular risk of compromise as the boundaries between their official duties and secondary employment may be blurred7.

Using official resources for secondary employment, or engaging in secondary employment while on duty, are also likely to cause a conflict of interest8.

Officers who are considering secondary employment should be mindful of the potential for conflicts of interest between their law enforcement duties and their other commitments, and seek advice and approval from their agency prior to commencing secondary employment.

High risk area — relationships and associations

Criminal entities may seek access to law enforcement through intimate relationships, family connections, professional associations or cultural and social links9. Long-term relationships between law enforcement officers and members or associates of criminal organisations may represent a significant corruption vulnerability if they are not declared10.

Criminal entities may attempt to compromise a law enforcement officer's loyalty to their agency by exploiting a relationship or association and creating a conflict of interest11.

Undeclared relationships between work colleagues, particularly between an employee and the employee's manager, may give rise to claims of favouritism and nepotism12.

Conflicts of interest may also occur where the parties to a relationship find their loyalty to one another is inconsistent with the integrity expectations of their agency13, for example, in cases where one of the parties to the relationship engages in misconduct and the other party decides not to report it.

High risk area – officers attempting to self-manage risk

Self-managing risk involves officers attempting to deal with integrity issues alone and failing to report matters or seek assistance through management or their agency's integrity framework. Self-managing risk exposes staff to compromise, and denies the employer the opportunity to understand, appreciate and deal with risk holistically14.

Senior and experienced officers may be particularly vulnerable if they decide to self-manage conflicts of interest given their ability to influence agency decision making15. Undeclared conflicts of interest may add weight to allegations of improper conduct and bring the validity of key decisions into question.

During an ACLEI investigation into a suspected inappropriate relationship between a law enforcement officer and a member of an organised crime group, it was determined that the officer initially self-assessed the relationship did not meet the threshold for declaration. While the officer ultimately declared the relationship, this only occurred after the officer became concerned for their safety and subsequently reported their concerns to their manager.

High risk area — ineffective notification, recording and training processes

Public sector agencies, including those in law enforcement, must maintain a suite of integrity measures to address the risks posed by actual and potential conflicts of interest.16 However, corruption vulnerability may increase where these integrity measures are not fit for purpose17.

For example, law enforcement officers should be made aware of potential conflicts of interest and their reporting obligations involving attendance at higher risk locations – that is, locations such as

7 NSW Police Force 2016 - https://www.police.nsw.gov.au/data/assets/pdf\_file/0020/301475/10\_COI\_Procedures\_437417\_15Sep2016.pdf

8 ibid

9 Strategic Centre for Organised Crime 2015 - <https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/individuals-at-risk-of-being-drawn-into-serious-and-organised-crime-a-prevent-guide>

10 ibid

11 Davids 2008 Conflict of interest in policing: problems, practices and principles. Institute of Criminology Press: Sydney.

12 VPSC 2018 - <https://vpsc.vic.gov.au/html-resources/managing-consensual-personal-relationships-practice-guide/2-conflict-interest-relationships/>

13 USQ 2018 - <https://www.usq.edu.au/hr/empcond/conflicts/conflict-examples>

14 ACLEI 2019 - <https://www.aclei.gov.au/corruption-prevention/key-concepts/glossary>

15 APSC 2018 - <https://www.apsc.gov.au/sect-411-conflict-interest>

16 ibid

17 ACLEI 2019 - <https://www.aclei.gov.au/corruption-prevention/key-concepts/what-best-approach-early-intervention>

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.