Documents › ea412e2eac6be48c7791dd0c7570a3358f7cc77c:1-12

City of Torrance Termination Letter - Brian Kawamoto

POST board disciplinediscipline and employment 2022-10-04 12 pages (file pages 1–12) original file
About this document
Layer
attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
Type as titled
termination letter (kind from doc_type)
File
ea412e2eac6be48c7791dd0c7570a3358f7cc77c application/pdf
Cases
POST 2305110 · Brian Kawamoto (filed under case)

About: Brian Kawamoto (case)

Page 8 · file page 8 larger image
Image of page 8; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

Brian Kawamoto
October 4, 2022
Page 8 of 12

offensive. You also admitted that you received departmental training on cultural diversity, and that you understood the “N word” is inappropriate, offensive, and should not be used professionally. Notwithstanding your training, you stated that the “N” word was used colloquially and as a term of endearment (akin to “brother” or “man”), and that in context, you took it as a joke. You stated that you did not know at the time that you were doing something wrong and/or violating applicable policies.

One exception was regarding Officer Weldin’s use of the term “nigglets,” which you assumed referred to Black children. You stated that you felt that term was offensive even when you initially received the text from Weldin, but you did not report it to anyone. You also acknowledged that with regard to the 11/21/2019 text sent by Weldin, “[i]n hindsight, I probably should have [reported it]. As the older guy, as a senior officer, I should have said something to him. It didn’t personally offend me, so I just let it ride and I shouldn’t have, sir.”

In reference to the 9/12/2019 text message cartoon depicting a Black male stabbing and robbing a white female, you admitted your perception of the cartoon was to affirm “the stereotype’s true that Black people commit crimes”. You admitted that while it is potentially offensive to a lot of people, you did not report or attempt to curtail it because it was not personally offensive to you.

Regarding the 12/24/2019 meme comparing a Black person to winter holiday decorations that you “hang”, you admitted to sending the photo because you thought the others receiving the text “might find it funny”, even though you understood that the premise of the meme was a reference to lynching.

III. ANALYSIS

In Skelly v. State Personnel Board (1975) 15 Cal.3d 194, the California Supreme Court stated that the “overriding consideration” when addressing whether a public employer has imposed an appropriate level of discipline is “the extent to which the employee’s conduct resulted in, or if repeated, is likely to result in, ‘harm to the public service.’” (Id. at 218.) “Other relevant factors include the circumstances surrounding the misconduct and the likelihood of its recurrence.” (Id.) In your particular case, the principles set forth in Skelly amply support your proposed discipline. In fact, the period between April 2019 and February 2020 establishes an ongoing pattern of misconduct and policy violations.

A. YOU ENGAGED IN INEXCUSABLE MISCONDUCT

Your involvement in discriminatory text messaging with other TPD officers demonstrates a lack of sound decision-making and unbecoming conduct that calls into question your fitness for duty as a police officer. You sent, received, and otherwise interacted with/responded to over a dozen blatantly discriminatory text messages from other members of TPD over the course of eleven months. By your own admissions, these messages were offensive, inappropriate, and unprofessional. You referred to Black people as “savage monkeys”, used the “N” word in conversation with your colleagues, and laughed at “jokes” involving the violent, extrajudicial execution of Black people.

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.