Documents › ea412e2eac6be48c7791dd0c7570a3358f7cc77c:1-12

City of Torrance Termination Letter - Brian Kawamoto

POST board disciplinediscipline and employment 2022-10-04 12 pages (file pages 1–12) original file
About this document
Layer
attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
Type as titled
termination letter (kind from doc_type)
File
ea412e2eac6be48c7791dd0c7570a3358f7cc77c application/pdf
Cases
POST 2305110 · Brian Kawamoto (filed under case)

About: Brian Kawamoto (case)

Page 11 · file page 11 larger image
Image of page 11; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

Brian Kawamoto
October 4, 2022
Page 11 of 12

VI. EMPLOYEE'S RESPONSE AND ADMINISTRATIVE CONFERENCE CHAIR ASSESSMENT

An in person administrative conference was held on this matter on September 7, 2022. You, your attorney, Maurice Sinsley of the Law Offices of Stone Busailah, LLP, Police Chief Jeremiah Hart, Lt. Charles Fisher and Senior Human Resources Analyst Robert Weinmeister, were all in attendance. At the administrative conference, I offered both you and your attorney an opportunity to provide me with additional information to consider before making my decision. Your attorney provided me with a document entitled Police Officer Brian Kawamoto - Response To Proposed Dismissal, which set forth your position regarding this matter. The letter also included several attachments, including performance evaluations and reviews, commendations, and thank you letters from residents and others.

Mr. Sinsley made a number of contentions which began with challenging the warrant that was associated with the origin of the text messages and his concerns that the Police Chief and the Torrance Police Department violated the California Electronic Communications Act. However, my understanding is that all of the arguments raised by Mr. Sinsley were set forth in a Motion to Suppress which was recently denied in its entirety by the Court in Anthony Chavez, et al. v. Torrance Police Department (Case No. BH014005 Memorandum of Decision). A true and correct copy of the Memorandum of Decision is attached hereto as Attachment A and incorporated by reference herein. In summary, the Court found that Penal Code section 1546.4 does not require suppression of the evidence in this matter, that the search warrant at issue did not violate section 1546.1(d)(1), that the Department's pending administrative investigation does not violate section 1546.1(d)(2), and that the City did not violate Judge Carter's order by reviewing messages or providing the messages to the DA's office. The Court also ruled that Attorney Corey Glave was not entitled to the return of his attorney-client communications which were captured in the search warrant data.4

I reviewed the letter and all of the documents presented by Mr. Sinsley in detail. Even if the terms "savages", as used in your 2/17/2020 text to Officer Weldin, is somehow not linked to any protected class (unless, by your admission, used with a qualifier such as "monkeys"), that does not change the fact that you sent and/or responded to numerous other discriminatory messages. Likewise, your own background as a mixed-race individual is not an "extenuating circumstance" that in any way mitigates your conduct; jokes based on racial stereotypes, slurs, and lynchings are not made less offensive by the race of the person making the reference. I therefore am unpersuaded that the recommended termination should be mitigated or overturned.

VII. ADMINISTRATIVE CONFERENCE CHAIR FINDING

Officer Kawamoto, I am wholeheartedly disappointed as the Administrative Conference Chair in rendering this decision in a case involving a Torrance Police Department Police Officer


4 It should be noted that the Administrative Conference Chair did not rely upon any attorney-client privileged communications in making the decision to terminate your employment.

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.