Documents › e628c297484336068eee0f6d3ca7839d2ba7b3d2:9-28
758 - BR01_POST2311370_Zavala_Jose_ISF_Redacted.pdf
About this document
- Layer
- packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
- Type as titled
- isf (kind from doc_type)
- File
- e628c297484336068eee0f6d3ca7839d2ba7b3d2 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Jose Zavala (case)
Page 19 · file page 27
larger image
Text: digital text layer
Investigative Summary and Recommendation
Jose ZAVALA (Respondent)
Case Number POST2311370
Page 19
direction toward the two officers did not significantly change the circumstances to
warrant a lethal response, and that the use of deadly force did not appear to be in
response to an imminent threat as defined by the California Penal Code.
B.
Summary of Findings
Based on a careful review of Respondent’s, QUINTANILLA’s, and other officer’s BWV
data, LAPD’s Tactical Concept No. 1128 (Edged Weapons), LAPD’s Use of Force
Policy29, an evaluation of crime scene documentation, and a review of various sections
of California Penal Code section 835a, Commission Regulation 1205(a)(3), in
conjunction with recent case law, the Division assesses that both Respondent’s and
QUINTANILLA’s belief that the Victim posed an imminent threat was not reasonable
and that their application of deadly force was based solely on a perceived or future
threat. BWV recordings depict the Victim standing up, taking four slow steps forward,
turning, and then stopping. At no point did the Victim vocalize any intent to harm officer
or others, attempt to leave the scene, conceal himself from officers, lunge, rapidly
advance, or make any sudden or furtive movements towards officers or others that
necessitated the use of deadly force.
While Victim certainly posed a threat to the community when he initially left his
residence armed with a kitchen knife, the Division carefully considered all of the relevant
circumstances during the approximately 18-minute incident and concluded that the
threat was not imminent at the moment deadly force was utilized because the Victim
was quickly contained, did not possess a particularly threatening demeanor and/or
intent to cause injury to officers or others, and only posed a danger to himself. Officers
were positioned between 22 and 30 feet from Victim and behind the cover of police
vehicles during the incident. There were no bystanders positioned closer to the Victim
than any officer and the occupants located inside the apartment building at
(behind Victim) had complied with officer’s orders to remain inside the
building with the door closed. Therefore, Respondent and QUINTANILLA failed to meet
the standard set forth under California Penal Code section 835a(c)(2). Specifically,
Respondent and QUINTANILLA’s use of deadly force against the Victim was based on
the danger the Victim posed to himself, not on an objectively reasonable belief that the
Victim posed an imminent threat of death or serious bodily injury to themselves or
another person.
Based on the totality of the evidence, the Division finds that reasonable grounds exist to
refer this case to the Peace Officer Standards Accountability Advisory Board and the
POST Commission for consideration of certificate revocation or suspension pursuant to
California Penal Code section 13510.8.
28 Attachment K (LAPD’s Tactical Concept No. 11 - Edged Weapons)
29 Attachment L (LAPD’s Use of Force Policy - 10/2020 – 8/2022)
Incident Location
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.