OCSD Use of Force Report 24-009233
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- use of force report (kind from doc_type)
- File
- d8ced334a3eb13f0d0546fddd973202040d9b02d application/pdf
- Cases
About: Armando R. Montalvo (case)
4/1/24, 8:01 AM
Use of Force: 24-009233
Were all witness statements memorialized in the Supervisory Analysis of this use of force incident?
Answer
Yes
Manager Question 2
Was the use of force subject interviewed and the statements memorialized in the Supervisory Supplement Report in FBR of this use of force incident?
Answer
Yes
Manager Question 3
Are there any areas of training to be addressed? If yes, what are they? Corrected Actions taken?
Answer
Yes
Instead of using controlling force against the inmate, injuring force was used. Upon review, the force appeared ineffective and inappropriate for this incident.
Manager Question 4
Are there any areas of liability or risk management concerns associated with this use of force event? If yes, what are they?
Answer
Yes
The inmate, along with the deputies using force were exposed to possible injury, in addition to possible policy violations by the deputies associated to this event.
Managerial Secondary Review
Use of Force on subjects released at the scene (includes cite and releases)
No
Arrests for PC 148, with no additional charges
Yes
Use of Force required admission to a hospital for medical treatment
No
Ineffective use of ECD where additional force required
No
Multiple deployments (drive stun, multiple cycles, more than one cartridge used) of the ECD
No
Secondary Review Required? Yes
Use of carotid restraint
No
Use of Force on subjects not involved in the original investigation (witnesses, passengers, etc.)
No
Use of less lethal munitions (40mm, 12 gauge super sock "bean bag") with no response from
Homicide
No
Sergeant involved in Use of Force
No
Recommendations and Conclusions
| Employee Name | Sgt. Recommendation | Cpt./Lt. Recommendation | Cmdr. Determination |
|---|---|---|---|
| Armando Montalvo | Refer incident to Command St... | Refer incident to Command St... | Refer incident to Command Staff with a recom... |
| Daniel Herrera | Refer incident to Command St... | Refer incident to Command St... | Refer incident to Command Staff with a recom... |
| Elvis Chen | Refer incident to Command St... | Refer incident to Command St... | Refer incident to Command Staff with a recom... |
| Justin Romo | Refer incident to Command St... | Refer incident to Command St... | Refer incident to Command Staff with a recom... |
7/8
Page 16 of 38
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.