OCSD Use of Force Report 24-009233
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- use of force report (kind from doc_type)
- File
- d8ced334a3eb13f0d0546fddd973202040d9b02d application/pdf
- Cases
About: Armando R. Montalvo (case)
4/1/24, 8:01 AM
Use of Force: 24-009233
Link to Video
<https://ocsdca.evidence...>
/axon/evidence?evidence\_id=2b1407ddd3b44d31a5028439b70940a3&p...
d=6c9fa7c272794e2f8ac66e8395b77249
Supervisor's Questions - INCOMPLETE (7 Questions Missing)
Question 1
What were the actions that led to this Use of Force?
At approximately 0415 hours, Inmate [REDACTED] (BKG: [REDACTED]) was being processed, and moved out of cell H-4 to have his initial booking photo taken. While moving from Cell H-4, [REDACTED] began to disregard direct orders from Deputies. Deputy A. Montalvo [REDACTED] grabbed [REDACTED] by the jacket to direct [REDACTED] to where he was ordered to stand for the booking photo. [REDACTED] bulled away and turned towards Dep. Montalvo.
Question 2
Were the force options or weapons in this incident effective?
Answer No
Please Explain Four Deputies punched Inmate [REDACTED] numerous times even though the inmate did not appear to be actively resisting.
Question 3
Were the force options or weapons utilized in this incident reasonable under Policy 300?
Answer No
Please Explain Policy 300 states, "Members shall use only that amount of force that appears objectively reasonable, given the facts and circumstances perceived by the Member at the time of the event, to effectively bring an incident under control."
The force used was not objectively reasonable or proportionate to the threat presented by the Inmate. The application of force did not stop even though the Inmate did not appear to be actively/physically resisting.
Question 4
Was relevant/necessary medical attention provided to department member(s) and the use of force subject(s) ?
Answer Yes
Please Explain
Question 5
5/8
Page 14 of 38
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.