Documents › d571ad0185fc211fdc57e18f33844e2b3984b6ca:388-400
326 - BR20_POST2300204_Hubbard_David_Reviewed_Attachment_S_Northern_Ireland_conflict_of_interest.pdf
About this document
- Layer
- packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
- Type as titled
- case_attachment (kind from title)
- File
- d571ad0185fc211fdc57e18f33844e2b3984b6ca application/pdf
- Cases
About: David Wesley Hubbard (case)
Page 11 · file page 398
larger image
Text: digital text layer
7
Article 2 Policy Considerations
7.1
When conducting investigations where Article 2 is engaged, the Police Ombudsman is
obliged to ensure that such investigations comply with the requirements of independence
under the European Convention and Human Rights Act. The are therefore specific
circumstances in which the Office considers that it may not be appropriate for staff from a
former RUC, PSNI or Military background to investigate certain matters.
7.2
While the requirement to maintain hierarchical and structural independence is met by the
independence of the Office from the PSNI, the additional requirement to ensure the
practical independence of those conducting an investigation from those under investigation
can present some difficulties.
7.3
Employees who previously served in the RUC or PSNI may have practical links to persons
under investigation in any given case and while there is no suggestion of impropriety on the
part of any employee, there will be situations where , through no fault of any individual
person, the Article 2 requirement would be breached by permitting certain employees from
investigating certain allegations.
7.4
Paragraph 7.5 below provides examples of situations in which a conflict of interest may arise
over and above those possible conflicts of interest detailed at section 4.4 above. Should a
conflict of interest arise, the employee concerned should immediately notify and seek
direction from their line manager.
7.5
Situations where direction from line management should be sought include
•
Where an investigator at any time served in a line management position relative to a person
under investigation (namely where they supervised or were supervised by the person under
investigation)
•
Where an investigator was in any way in any capacity linked to the incident under
investigation
•
Where a police policy is the subject of the investigation and the investigator was in any way
involved with the setting or maintenance of that policy
This list is not exhaustive and as in 4.5 above where an investigator has any doubt as to their
practical independence, they should seek direction from line management
7.6
On occasions where practical independence is impacted management may remove an
investigator from a particular Article 2 investigation. This step is necessary to ensure
compliance with legislation, to protect the integrity of the investigation, protect the
individual investigator and to maintain confidence in the police complaints system. Such a
decision does not suggest any improper conduct on the part of the investigator concerned.
7.7
It is possible that a conflict of interest may not be immediately apparent at the outset of an
investigation but that an issue may arise during the course of enquiries. In such
9
398
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.