Documents › d571ad0185fc211fdc57e18f33844e2b3984b6ca:223-254
326 - BR1_POST2300204_Hubbard_David_Redacted_Hubbard_Final_ISF.pdf
About this document
- Layer
- packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
- Type as titled
- isf (kind from doc_type)
- File
- d571ad0185fc211fdc57e18f33844e2b3984b6ca application/pdf
- Cases
About: David Wesley Hubbard (case)
Page 18 · file page 240
larger image
Text: digital text layer
Investigative Summary and Findings
David Wesley Hubbard (Respondent)
Case Number POST2300204
Page 18 of 32
The clear and convincing evidence established that Respondent deleted
relevant information from his work cell phone after learning on November 23, 2021,
that Suspect 1 alleged that Respondent and Victim 1 were having an affair. The clear
and convincing evidence substantiated that Respondent deleted the following
information:36
Dates
Type of Deleted Data
11/5/2021-11/17/2021
Calls
11/8/2021-11/17/2021
Texts
11/17/2021-11/30/2021
Calls
11/22/2021-11/30/2021
Texts
Respondent’s statements to me during his Internal Affairs investigation that he
did not delete any information after he was notified that he had to relinquish his work
cell phone during the Internal Affairs investigation into the allegation are misleading.
The relevant inquiry for me is whether Respondent had knowledge of the potential that
the information was evidence in Sergeant Perez’s investigation. Respondent did not
inform his supervisor of the affair until December 4, 2021,37 the day after Victim 1’s
boyfriend already reported the affair to KCSO. KCSO did not initiate the Internal Affairs
investigation until December 6, 2021. If Respondent’s statements are true, then
Respondent deleted some or all of his work cell phone logs and texts at some point
during the two-week period after he learned that Suspect 1 had alleged an affair
between Respondent and Victim 1, and that Sergeant Perez may need to interview
both Respondent and Victim 1 as part of the Suspect 1 Internal Affairs investigation.
The evidence showed that Respondent was an experienced investigator and
ranking officer at KCSO who knew the significance of the data that he deleted and that
he was likely to be asked to produce his work cell phone. Respondent had just learned
that Suspect 1 accused Respondent of having an affair with Victim 1 and knew that any
telephone logs and text messages between Respondent and Victim 1 could
corroborate Suspect 1’s claims. I find that there is a high probability that Respondent
knew that the data from his work cell phone would be evidence in both the Internal
Affairs investigation into Suspect 1’s conduct and a likely future investigation into
Respondent’s own conduct due to the probative value the allegation had for Suspect
1’s defense to Victim 1’s allegations, as well as in the inevitable Internal Affairs
investigation into Suspect 1’s allegations and that he deleted the data intentionally to
hide it from the Internal Affairs investigator.
36 Attachment H (Respondent IA Case Report at 20).
37 Victim 1 told her partner that she had an affair with Respondent on December 3, 2021.
240
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.