Documents › cafadb97f9e09972e2d29e5d0c29e31d4b32822f:1-5

Mora Richard Notice of Determination

Certification Actions commission decisionboard proceeding 5 pages (file pages 1–5) original file
About this document
Layer
cert order: part of a file an agency produced
Type as titled
notice of determination (kind from doc_type)
Produced as
https://post.ca.gov/Portals/0/post_docs/Certification_Actions/Module/Mora_Richard_Notice_of_Determination.pdf
File
cafadb97f9e09972e2d29e5d0c29e31d4b32822f application/pdf
Cases
POST 2321280 · MORA, RICHARD T (case number)

About: MORA, RICHARD T (case)

Page 3 · file page 3 larger image
Image of page 3; its text is alongside
Text: OCR figure: some text describes an image

STATE OF CALIFORNIA
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE

GAVIN NEWSOM, Governor
ROB BONTA, Attorney General

Figure: the OCR model's description, not text on the pageSeal of the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training, featuring a star with a torch and scales of justice.The seal of the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training is a seven-pointed star. In the center of the star is a circular emblem containing a torch and scales of justice. The words "COMMISSION ON PEACE OFFICER STANDARDS AND TRAINING" are written around the perimeter of the star.

Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training

Peace Officer Standards Accountability Division
860 Stillwater Road, Suite 100
West Sacramento, CA 95605
www.post.ca.gov

Victim's body, which was now lying prone, face down on the sidewalk. Blake Dudley covered the team on the ground with a less-than-lethal shotgun from a few feet away.

Respondent's own BWC captures clear images of his knee on Victim's head. The first such image is captured for a fraction of a second at 12:43:03 p.m. For the 11 seconds between 12:43:07 p.m. and 12:43:18 p.m., the image is more stable, recording Respondent's knee on Victim's head for that entire time. The BWC angle then changes, and Victim's head is no longer visible, coinciding with Respondent changing his body posture from one that is hunched over Victim to a posture that is more upright, which aligns his body weight more fully on Victim's head.

Of particular significance is the period of time between 12:43:19 p.m. and 12:43:24 p.m. as seen from the perspective captured by Dudley's BWC. During those five seconds, Respondent appears to bounce his weight up and down to apply extra force on the Victim's head. Respondent's own BWC does not capture this, as it is pointed directly toward the police badge of Officer Booth. Between 12:43:21 p.m. and 12:43:25 p.m., however, Respondent's BWC image jerks up and down at least three times coinciding with the rocking motion captured on Dudley's BWC.

Officers succeeded in securing one cuff on the Victim at 12:43:14 p.m. and the second cuff at 12:43:24 p.m. The officers who were on top of the Victim, including Respondent, rose up and were off him by 12:43:27 p.m., exactly 30 seconds after taking him to the ground. The situation was fast and dynamic, with five officers exerting themselves in a very limited physical space in a short period of time.

In IA interviews, all present at the scene indicated Victim was not "physically assaultive," i.e., he was not trying to assault the officers but rather resisted being put into handcuffs. Respondent himself stated that Victim "wasn't combative, he wasn't trying to assault anybody." These impressions were corroborated by BWC video, which showed the Victim tensing his body and attempting to pull away until he was restrained. Based upon that level of resistance, three of the officers who engaged Victim at the scene told IA that placing a knee on his head and neck was neither necessary nor reasonable. Booth, for example, characterized this as "excessive force...especially for the situation."

The statements made by two other officers potentially introduced an element of ambiguity in a use-of-force assessment. Surratt, who held the Victim's left wrist, stated it may have been necessary to place a knee on his neck and head "since [the Victim] was not handcuffed and due to his behavior," although he qualified that response by noting it was not reasonable to bounce up and down. Camacho, who held the Victim's other wrist, indicated Respondent's knee could have slipped since the incident unfolded so quickly. Notably, these opinions did not directly contradict the other officers but instead reflected their different perspectives during the incident. Surratt still held that Respondent's rocking on the Victim's head was unreasonable, while

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.