Documents › c79e0e4555d81c581de95c2ba65e73ed2a56d74b:9-28
-805- - BR01_POST2507244_EscarenoDavila Eduardo_ISF.pdf
About this document
- Layer
- packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
- Type as titled
- isf (kind from doc_type)
- File
- c79e0e4555d81c581de95c2ba65e73ed2a56d74b application/pdf
- Cases
About: Eduardo Escareno-Davila (case)
Page 17 · file page 25
larger image
Text: digital text layer
Investigative Summary and Findings
Eduardo Guadalupe Escareno-Davila
Case Number POST2507244
Page 17
that when Respondent touched her, “it was definitely like he was about to penetrate but
he didn’t penetrate.” When asked what he was about to penetrate with, Victim said, “His
fingers. Two fingers.” During her interview with the detective, Victim said that she initially
saw Respondent on the floor next to her bed, and his joggers were pulled up so she
assumed he had touched her with his fingers, but since it took a moment between when
she first felt the touch and when she saw Respondent, she didn’t know if his joggers
had been partially pulled down during the contact. Since Victim was asleep prior to
feeling the touch, she also didn’t know how long he had been in her bed with her. She
didn’t feel him get into the bed, so she was unsure if he had touched her with his fingers
or his penis.
Although Respondent denied touching Victim’s vagina, he also made some statements
that cast doubt on the credibility of his denial. First, when Respondent was
demonstrating on video how he reached up to touch Victim, it was noted that at one
point his hand was near the middle of the bed, where Victim reported her waist would
have been if she was lying down in the bed. When Respondent was initially describing
his actions during the incident, he said, “And then I reached, reached up a little bit more.
I think I touched somewhere up here. I don’t know where else.” Later during his
interview, when asked if he started to move his hand upwards after touching Victim’s
heel, Respondent replied, “I don’t know what I did after that.” Toward the end of the
interview, Detective Woida confronted Respondent and told him that he had already
spoken to Victim and believed her account of the incident. Respondent retorted saying
that he wasn’t going to lie and retold his version of the incident, “I stood by her door and
then, like I told you, I think I told you, I kind of stepped in, walked out, like, what are you
doing? And I went in, laid by her bed and it all happened. But like I was telling him, I
only touched on here to my knowledge, and then I moved my hand up a little bit,
touched something else, and I was like, and then she woke up and that’s when she was
like, what are you doing and called 9-1-1.”
So, after Respondent’s third statement indicating his uncertainty of where else he
touched Victim besides the heel of her foot and possibly her calf, Detective Woida
asked him what the “something else” was that he said he touched and Respondent
replied, “I don’t know. Just skin.” Detective Woida then said, “So it’s, it’s possible that
that was her vagina then? If you don’t know what you, if you don’t know what you
touched, how do you know what you,” at which point Respondent interrupted him and
said, “It was just like skin.” Respondent then elaborated and said, “Because I, um,
honestly, we’re adults here. I know what a vagina feels like, and it was definitely not her
vagina.”
If Respondent was being truthful when he made the multiple statements indicating his
uncertainty about what other parts of Victim’s body he touched, specifically when he
said, “I don’t know where else,” “I don’t know what I did after that,” and that he “touched
something else,” then, he did not recall or realize what he touched in his inebriated
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.