LA County District Attorney Charge Evaluation Worksheet J.S.I.D. File #20-0226R (Braulio Robledo)
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- da charge evaluation (kind from doc_type)
- File
- c0c523df384785169eeeabeaecdd46d87f53a563 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Braulio Robledo (case)
Charge Evaluation Worksheet
J.S.I.D. File #20-0226R
L.A.S.D. File #920-00011-2003-441
July 14, 2023
Page 16 of 17
With the current state of the evidence, there is insufficient evidence to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Robledo stole from [REDACTED] V1
The only evidence that a theft occurred comes from [REDACTED] V1's statements. [REDACTED] V1 confirmed at his house, away from any cameras or other witnesses, that he was a victim of theft. He based his conclusion on the total amount of white chips he believed he had when he left the casino compared to how many white chips he had when he arrived home.
Although the law allows a single witness to prove a fact, jurors are specifically directed to "carefully review all the evidence" prior to concluding a fact is proven by a single witness. Additionally, jurors are directed to look at whether "other evidence proves or disproves any fact about which the witness testified to" in evaluating the accuracy of a witness's testimony.
[REDACTED] V1 stated multiple times that he placed 15 white poker chips in his bag. He stated that he triple counted his money and that the Commerce Casino surveillance cameras would corroborate this fact. Armed with this knowledge, [REDACTED] V1 stated he knew the deputy took five white poker chips since he only had ten left over when he arrived home.
[REDACTED] V1, however, was wrong. The casino surveillance appears to show that [REDACTED] V1 had 13 white chips, not 15, when he left the Commerce Casino. Thus, Robledo may not have taken five white poker chips if [REDACTED] V1 still had ten in his possession after the traffic stop. Therefore, [REDACTED] V1 may have been wrong about how many $100 white chips were missing after the traffic stop. Further, [REDACTED] V1 specifically stated that no cash was taken. Since [REDACTED] V1 had an app tracker that counted the amount of money with which he walked away from the casino, it is possible that [REDACTED] V1 was confused as to the source of the missing $500. It is possible that [REDACTED] V1 thought he had 15 white chips, when in fact he had 13. It is possible that the additional two white chips [REDACTED] V1 believe he had were actually accounted for in cash and that Robledo actually stole a combination of chips and cash totaling $500. On the other hand, it is also possible that [REDACTED] V1 simply miscounted the amount of cash and chips he had when he returned home, similar to his miscalculation of the number of white chips in his possession when he left the casino, and that, in fact, no money was stolen during the police encounter.
As such, a follow up interview with [REDACTED] V1 is necessary to determine if he can sufficiently explain his error in calculations. As noted in detail above, the LASD and the District Attorney's Office have made many attempts to locate [REDACTED] V1 [REDACTED] V1's whereabouts remain unknown. Further, there is no indication that even if located, [REDACTED] V1 will cooperate with law enforcement, as evidenced by [REDACTED] V1's clear refusals in past email communications to participate with law enforcement interviews.
Based on [REDACTED] V1's potential error in what was missing after the traffic stop, his subsequent refusals to cooperate with law enforcement, his unknown location, and his
LASD-000039 RELEASE DATE: 7/29/2024
117
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.