Documents › be19e27c4d932292ae3b121c6eed20e47930d4ad:1-2

POST Interview of Bess Rutter

POST board interview transcriptagency investigation 2023-05-03 2 pages (file pages 1–2) original file
About this document
Layer
attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
Type as titled
interview transcript (kind from doc_type)
File
be19e27c4d932292ae3b121c6eed20e47930d4ad application/pdf
Cases
POST 2300204 · David Wesley Hubbard (filed under case)

About: David Wesley Hubbard (case)

Page 2 · file page 2 larger image
Image of page 2; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

Interview of Bess Rutter
May 3, 2023
Page 2

As a woman, Rutter saw red flags about Hubbard's and [REDACTED] relationship. [REDACTED] was a very flirtatious individual. She is very outgoing and Rutter put it all together after the fact.

[REDACTED] drank some tea and had an allergic reaction and almost fainted. Hubbard may have picked her up. Rutter did not see that.

Rutter asked Justin Weidenkopf a few months into working at PSU what the reason was for [REDACTED] to work for Hubbard. It was odd because [REDACTED] should have reported to a sergeant, not directly to a lieutenant. Weidenkopf did not answer directly, and replied only that was just how Hubbard decided to do it.

Hubbard did not have personal animosity toward [REDACTED] When Rutter was in IA, [REDACTED] was a subject officer and Hubbard was in detectives at the time. Hubbard was [REDACTED] supervisor at the time of [REDACTED] IA incident.

Rutter did not know if Hubbard and [REDACTED] were holding hands or kissing.

There were rumors that Hubbard was trying to get involved in the criminal investigation of [REDACTED] People were upset and wondered why he was trying to do that. During Rutter's time in PSU, it was before Hubbard left the unit at the end of 2021. Rutter heard he was inserting himself by speaking with the District Attorney. It seemed later on that she heard that rumor after Hubbard had left. Rutter did not know if Hubbard inserted himself into the IA investigation of [REDACTED]

In November 2021, Rutter was in the office over the weekend of November 21-22. She recalled the office light or desk lamp was on in Hubbard's office. At about that time, Rutter was suspicious that Hubbard and [REDACTED] were having an affair or something was going on. She wanted to get out of the office as fast as possible because she had suspicions. She did not see Hubbard's car. She thought his light on was odd. She knew Hubbard was watch commander that weekend. Based on her suspicions, she asked around if Hubbard was in his office. She wanted confirmation of her suspicions.

Hubbard was a good supervisor. Smart guy. He guided you, didn't tell you what to do. Rutter learned a lot from him in IA and he recommended her to come over to work for him in PSU. She would not feel comfortable talking to him behind closed doors.

Hubbard treated [REDACTED] differently than others he supervised, including support staff. Rutter did not see Hubbard abuse his power. From outside looking in, [REDACTED] appeared to cross the line in joking with Hubbard. [REDACTED] treated Hubbard more like a peer than her supervisor. Hubbard did not reciprocate. He didn't really respond to her but every now and then he did. He was not as outlandish as she was. [REDACTED] was more flirtatious than he was. She was more flirtatious with Hubbard than anyone else. It was more words. She did not dress provocatively but would talk close to his face. She was like that with everyone. Within a group, everyone engaged in innuendo and Rutter can't say [REDACTED] did that more than others. [REDACTED] did aim innuendo at Hubbard to see his reaction.

Hubbard treatly everyone the same if they came in late for work. Rutter had to make up work on the back end of her shift. It was common for [REDACTED] to be late for work.


The mission of the California Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training is to continually enhance the professionalism of California law enforcement in serving its communities.

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.