Mastagni Holstedt Request for Pre-disciplinary Hearing and Discovery - Officer James Guy
About this document
- Layer
- agency record: part of a file an agency produced
- Type as titled
- legal correspondence (kind from doc_type)
- Produced as
- porterville-police-department/22P37416-16.pdf
- File
- a61d9fa7c532e4400229c4f2eb23534b253d8f48 application/pdf
- Cases
this information is discoverable pursuant to the MMBA, Government Code section 3500 et.seq.1 as well as at appeal stages beyond the Skelly hearing which extends your duty to preserve and disclose this information.
My client is entitled to all information necessary and relevant to the discharge of its duty of representation. (Stockton Unified School District ("Stockton") (1980) PERB Decision No. 143.) POA's duty of representation includes representation in potential disciplinary matters and determining whether conduct is retaliatory based on concerted activity. (See State of California (Department of Consumer Affairs) ("Consumer Affairs") (2004) PERB Decision No. 1711-S.) PERB uses a liberal standard, similar to a discovery-type standard, to determine relevance of the requested information. (California State University (1986) PERB Decision No. 613-H.)
The City has a duty to notify its employees of this request and their obligation to retain records. (See City of San Jose v. Superior Court (2017) 2 Cal.5th 608, 627-28.) When a union is considering whether to exercise its right to represent employees in a meeting or proceeding that may adversely affect employment status, or the union does exercise that right, an employer may not deny the union's related information request on the basis that the meeting or proceeding is extra-contractual or that the union has no duty of fair representation, as union has right to information necessary or relevant to its right to represent bargaining unit employees. (United Faculty of Contra Costa County Community College (2019) PERB Decision No. 2652.).
Furthermore, claims of privilege due to the deliberative process are not a valid defense to the information request. (See Trustees of the California State University (2004) PERB Decision No. 1591-H, pp. 2-3). Fina
Penal Code § 135.5 places requirements on information that must be provided to a public safety officer during any disciplinary proceeding. It is unlawful to conceal any relevant evidence during the disciplinary process. Concealment would include knowingly not providing any relevant evidence.
While some of the following materials have been previously provided, please identify the items which have not been already provided and forward them to my office at your earliest convenience. On behalf of my client, I request the following information:
-
- A current copy of all policies and procedures alleged to have been violated by my client.
-
- All written reports prepared as a result of the allegations against my client.
-
- All investigator notes.
1 United Faculty of Contra Costa County Community College (2019) PERB Decision No. 2652.
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.