POST Investigative Summary and Findings - Jose Zavala (POST2311370)
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- investigative summary (kind from doc_type)
- File
- a2f0623025f73a31e5b9f5882b332825c53056ff application/pdf
- Cases
About: Jose Zavala (case)
I. Executive Summary and Findings1
On December 18, 2021, [REDACTED] Victim, hereinafter Victim, walked out of his residence holding a kitchen knife,2 threatened members of the community, and then sat idle on the steps of a neighboring residence while holding the knife to his neck. Officers assigned to LAPD's Newton Patrol Division (NPD) and Newton Gang Enforcement Detail (GED) responded to the "attempt suicide" call for service within minutes and contained Victim. Officer Jose ZAVALA, hereinafter Respondent,3 and his partner, Officer Julio QUINTANILLA, responded to the incident, established a perimeter position to the west of Victim, and were designated by the on-scene incident commander, [REDACTED] Sergeant, as lethal cover officers.
After approximately 13 minutes of de-escalation efforts, Victim stood up and took four slow steps forward and then stopped. This movement triggered LAPD's deployment of a less-lethal projectile, which struck Victim in the hip. Nearly contemporaneously (.382 seconds after the less-lethal deployment), from a distance of approximately 25 feet and behind the cover of a police vehicle, Respondent fired three rounds from his service pistol, striking Victim. Approximately .322 seconds after Respondent discharged his third round, QUINTANILLA, from a distance of approximately 28 feet and behind the cover of a police vehicle, fired a single round from his service pistol. Victim was detained but ultimately succumbed to the injuries sustained from the use of force.
LAPD's Force Investigation Division (FID) investigated the Officer Involved Shooting (OIS) and the results were conveyed to the LAPD Use of Force Review Board (UOFRB). The UOFRB was critical of Respondent's and QUINTANILLA's perception of an "immediate threat" and found that their actions were not objectively reasonable, proportional, or necessary. A subsequent Department-initiated Complaint Investigation reached a SUSTAINED finding of "Out of Policy – Administrative Disapproval" regarding Respondent's use of force. The incident was not referred to LAPD's Board of Rights (BOR), as the Chief of Police (COP) did not seek Respondent's and QUINTANILLA's termination. Ultimately, Respondent received a 10-day suspension and QUINTANILLA received a 5-day suspension with loss of pay and benefits.
Later, on February 3, 2023, the Victim's family filed a complaint, which initiated a second Complaint Investigation, alleging Respondent's and QUINTANILLA's excessive use of force. The investigation ultimately reached the finding of UNFOUNDED. In July of
1 Attachment A (Executive Review and Division Recommendation).
2 The first officer to arrive on scene described the knife as a "big butcher knife type meat clever." LAPD's FID Investigative report described the knife as a "meat clever" with a 6.5-inch blade and a 5.25-inch black plastic handle.
3 Attachment B (Respondent's EDI Profile).
Investigative Summary and Recommendation
Jose ZAVALA (Respondent)
Case Number POST2311370
Page 3
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.