Documents › 7f66e395837cac28f0dc322c0252403ff1a7e1c9:21-220

342 - 11.30.23_Transcript_Commission

POST board interview transcriptagency investigation 2024-03-07 200 pages (file pages 21–220) original file
About this document
Layer
packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
Type as titled
transcript (kind from title)
File
7f66e395837cac28f0dc322c0252403ff1a7e1c9 application/pdf
Cases
none: board business or reference material
Page 167 · file page 187 larger image
Image of page 167; its text is alongside
Text: digital text layer
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
POST Commission Meeting, November 30, 2023
KATHRYN S. SWANK, CSR, RPR    (916) 390-7731
167
intolerance, et cetera, toward individuals in a 
protected class.  
As you know, the law and our regulation has a First 
Amendment carveout, and this gets into a very 
interesting area for us lawyers, looking at the 
intersection or the question between free speech rights 
and our regulatory ability to take action.  
So what we've tried to do with this exemplar 
language to facilitate this discussion or to get the 
Commission's ideas is to walk that line so that we, 
staff, can have a little bit better guidance from staff 
with respect to how the Commission views "demonstrating 
bias." 
So what we tried to do in this language is, to get 
over the arguments that there's a pure First Amendment 
right to engage in speech, no matter how negative that 
it might be, is to tie that speech to instances where a 
reasonable person looking at that speech would conclude 
that the officer would not be able to fairly and 
impartially perform; or if we do have evidence that the 
officer actually did not fairly and impartially perform 
his or her duties because that bias/intolerance/  
contempt toward people within that protected class.  
So we might get cases, for instance, where there 
has simply been an officer expressing a view against 
187

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.