Garcia Francisco Notice of Determination
About this document
- Layer
- cert order: part of a file an agency produced
- Type as titled
- notice of determination (kind from doc_type)
- Produced as
- https://post.ca.gov/Portals/0/post_docs/Certification_Actions/Module/Garcia_Jr._Francisco_Notice_of_Determination_Redacted.pdf
- File
- 5749baadb3f22c82691b26d85c18b1aa9a8ca14b application/pdf
- Cases
About: GARCIA, FRANCISCO (case)
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
GAVIN NEWSOM, Governor
ROB BONTA, Attorney General
Figure: the OCR model's description, not text on the pageSeal of the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and TrainingThe seal of the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training, featuring a seven-pointed star with various symbols in the center, including a scale of justice and a sword.
Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training
Peace Officer Standards Accountability Division
860 Stillwater Road, Suite 100
West Sacramento, CA 95605
www.post.ca.gov
The Respondent's denial of sleeping on duty was highly probable to be dishonest based on the following clear and convincing evidence:
- • An independent witness provided photographic evidence of the Respondent parked, seated in the driver's seat of his patrol vehicle, with his head tilted back, his eyes closed, and jaw relaxed.
- • An independent witness explained that she knocked on the patrol vehicle's window, and the Respondent did not wake up.
- • After being presented photographic evidence, the Respondent changed his statement when he stated, "Yes so ok so the whole sleeping thing, I honestly don't remember sleeping ok if I was asleep then I was asleep right I'm I'm not that picture looks horrible it looks like I was asleep and if I was asleep then I was asleep."
- • The Respondent ultimately explained, "if that lady knocked on my window I made a I made a mistake I made a huge mistake I see I see the picture if I fell asleep I fell asleep I made I messed up I fell asleep however I don't remember falling asleep I don't even remember I don't even remember if when Corporal Muller called me and my phone even ring I remember talking to him so maybe yeah it looks like I I did fall asleep but I don't remember I don't remember falling asleep."
During the incident and during the internal affairs interview, it is established with high probability the Respondent was dishonest when he denied drinking on duty:
- • When the Lieutenant and Corporal confronted the Respondent with sleeping on duty, the Lieutenant smelled the odor of an alcoholic beverage emitting from his person and asked the Respondent if he had been drinking. The Respondent chuckled and stated he had not had anything to drink since last week. When the Lieutenant told the Respondent he smelled a fruity alcoholic beverage odor coming from his breath, the Respondent related it was his fruity flavored vape-pen.1
- • When CHP was conducting the criminal investigation, the Respondent was asked a series of pre-FST questions and was asked, "What have you been drinking?" and the Respondent stated, "I had a Red Bull earlier and some mouthwash about an hour ago" and "I did drink a little bit of mouthwash." When asked, "How much?" the Respondent stated, "Ah it was an accident." The Respondent was asked again, "Like how much mouthwash?" and the Respondent stated, "I mean I don't know, I took a swig, I swallowed some of it and spit out the rest."
- • During the internal affairs interview, the Respondent made the following statements:
- ○ "...we were in the Sergeant's Office and that's when I'm talking to Corporal and he says he over there I do actually smell alcohol in you on your breathe"
1 Statements made during the preliminary administrative investigation are based on the Lieutenant and Corporal's recollection of events. With the exception of the civilian interview, there is no BWC recordings leading up to CHP's arrival.
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.