Documents › 44b32bde1f1bf4beadbfe964cfff72645fb80a65:27-33

San Diego Police Department Officer Report 20408 and IA Investigation Report #2020-0233

POST board investigation reportagency investigation 2020-12-15 7 pages (file pages 27–33) original file
About this document
Layer
attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
Type as titled
ia investigation report (kind from doc_type)
File
44b32bde1f1bf4beadbfe964cfff72645fb80a65 application/pdf
Cases
POST 2300809 · Dillon Fuston (filed under case)

About: Dillon Fuston (case)

Page 3 · file page 29 larger image
Image of page 3; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

CONFIDENTIAL – DO NOT DUPLICATE

Investigator's Report

Complaint: I.A. #2020-0233

Page 53

throughout the apartment I feared there may be another knife in the bed with [S1]. While Officer Fuston may have thought [S1] was reaching for his waistband, his reasoning is based on an unsubstantiated threat or unreasonable belief that everyone is armed until he pats them down. When Officer Fuston pushed [S1] onto the bed, [S1] left arm was in front of his body. From Officer Fuston's BWC and statement, Officer Fuston pulled [S1] right arm behind his back and applied downward pressure to [S1] back, thus, pushing [S1] onto his stomach on top of his left arm. This essentially trapped [S1] left arm underneath his body on a soft bed with downward pressure from Officer Fuston, who weighs 270 lbs.

Although it's appropriate for Officer Fuston to consider the possibility a person could have a weapon, as a factor for using force, his statement that it's his belief that everyone has a weapon until he pats them down is not practical or reasonable. An officer needs to [S1] clear and specific facts as to why he believes a person is armed with a weapon in order to perform a "pat down," unless consent is given. Officer Fuston's belief [S1] was armed with a deadly weapon is not supported by the details related to this radio call or his report. The facts of this radio call and the events preceding Officer Fuston delivering six punches to [S1's] back are as follows:

  • • On the notes of the radio call there was no mention of a weapon.
  • • Tait did not mention any weapons were used when she spoke with officers.
  • • The steak knife on the kitchen table was a few feet away from the kitchen and it was no longer in [S1] reach once Officer Fuston moved the table.
  • • Officers did not check the bed for weapons prior to waking [S1].
  • • The officers rolled [S1] onto his back and had a clear view of [S1] waistband for several seconds.
  • • During Officer Fuston's verbal commands to [S1], there was no mention of weapons or statements indicating [S1] was believed to be armed.
  • • Officer Fuston or Officer Campante did not pat down [S1] until he was taken outside the apartment into the hallway.
  • • Neither officer performed a pat down of the bed or the surrounding area once [S1] was taken into custody.
  • • Neither officer made note of a specific weapon in their report, besides the steak knife on the kitchen table.

Therefore, Officer Fuston's statement that he believed [S1] had immediate access to a deadly weapon is not supported by specific articulable facts that would lead a reasonable officer to believe [S1] had or was reaching for a weapon at the time Officer Fuston punched him six times.

Reporting Officer: Robert Davis, Detective Sergeant ID: 6781 Division Internal Affairs
Approved by: Stephen Shebloski, Lieutenant Date of Report: December 15, 2020

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.