POST Investigative Summary and Findings: Eduardo Escareno-Davila (POST2507244)
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- investigative summary and findings (kind from doc_type)
- File
- 3ff1e55e0638f36b9c157dd218427ce12f327db5 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Eduardo Escareno-Davila (case)
state. However, these statements of uncertainty could have also simply been a lie. Moreover, his explanation for how he knew he didn't touch Victim's vagina because "I know what a vagina feels like," lacks credibility. Respondent's denials further lack credibility because when he was demonstrating on video how he reached up to touch Victim, it was noted that at one point his hand was near the middle of the bed, where Victim reported her waist would have been if she was lying down in the bed.
Conversely, Victim's credibility was assessed to be high based on several factors:
- • Her multiple statements to dispatch, the initial responding deputy, and the subsequent detective, which was also used as the justification in the EPO and the statement of probable cause in the search warrant affidavit, were all consistent.
- • The specific details, which were mostly consistent with Respondent's version of the incident, provided by Victim also tend to strengthen her credibility. For example, she said that while she was asleep, she woke up because she felt something cold between her legs, near her vagina, after which she partially sat up while sleeping on her side. Victim also described the feeling of the touch near her vagina like an animal's nose, but it was larger.
- • Victim was wearing loose-fitting sleep shorts with no underwear and a T-shirt, which made the direct skin-to-skin contact of her vaginal area plausible.
- • When the initial responding deputy asked her if she wanted to press charges against Respondent, she asked for some time to think about it before eventually deciding to do so. It appeared that her hesitation was based on this being a first-time isolated incident with Respondent after having been cordial roommates for almost a year and his repeated apologies immediately after the incident.61
- • There is no known motive for her to have fabricated the disputed allegation that Respondent touched her vaginal area. In fact, Victim provided Respondent a bag and a glass of water when he started vomiting after the incident "because, you know, he needs taking care of, of course, after that." This act of compassion for Respondent, even after she had been violated by him, tends to show the absence of contempt or a motive to fabricate the key disputed detail about the incident (i.e., touching her vaginal area).
- • Victim's uncertainty about how long Respondent had been in bed with her prior to feeling him touch her vaginal area, because she had been asleep and didn't feel
61 Initial Victim interview with responding deputies – Attachment H (10:23 – 11:03 and 17:12 – 17:15)
Investigative Summary and Findings
Eduardo Guadalupe Escareno-Davila
Case Number POST2507244
Page 18
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.