Documents › 3cef2e7188f30138a1e0236eb848ccb3a2b05d5e:1-16

Alameda PD Personnel Complaint Investigation Summary IA 15-02 (Officer Stephen Mitchell)

Agency records investigation reportagency investigation 2015-03-05 Alameda Police Department 16 pages (file pages 1–16) original file
About this document
Layer
agency record: part of a file an agency produced
Type as titled
ia investigation report (kind from doc_type)
Produced as
alameda-police-department/Personnel Complaint Investigation Summary_Redacted.pdf
File
3cef2e7188f30138a1e0236eb848ccb3a2b05d5e application/pdf
Cases
agency:C-5dad5a53aa · Stephen Mitchell (record)

About: Stephen Mitchell (case)

Page 15 · file page 15 larger image
Image of page 15; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

Paul J. Rolleri
Chief of Police

March 5, 2015
Page 14 of 15

their academies and in the Alameda Police Department Field Training Program. Their academy instruction and field training taught them that warrants are judge issued commands to peace officers to take a named person into custody and bring them before a judge or magistrate.

As a result of their erroneous belief, the officers did not perform their duties as directed by law and departmental practice. The officers failed to arrest [REDACTED], knowing that she had an outstanding misdemeanor arrest warrant.

For both Officer [REDACTED] and Officer Mitchell, the allegation of violating performance of duty, specifically in regards to Policy 340.3.5(q) (Failure to Take Reasonable Action), is SUSTAINED.

Recommendation:

Neither Officer [REDACTED] nor Officer Mitchell has any prior disciplinary history. Sergeant Klaus started individual training sessions with Officer [REDACTED] and Officer Mitchell regarding their understanding of warrant arrests. The training sessions precipitated this internal investigation and they were cut short due to the investigation. It is recommended that Sergeant Klaus complete and document the training session with Officer [REDACTED].

Officer Mitchell's conduct in this incident did not reflect favorably upon himself or the Alameda Police Department. His deliberate untruthfulness as a police officer brought dishonor to the law enforcement profession. As a result of his actions, Officer Mitchell's name must now be disclosed to the Alameda County District Attorney's Office for placement on their Brady List. All future prosecutions of cases involving Officer Mitchell as an arresting officer or witness officer will be highly scrutinized, if not dismissed, because of his undermined credibility and potential to be easily impeached as a witness. This will continue to bring discredit to the Alameda Police Department as long as Officer Mitchell remains an employee.

Officer Mitchell's probationary period as an employee ends in December, 2015. It is recommended that Officer Mitchell be released from probation immediately and separated from service with the Alameda Police Department.

Referred to Disciplinary Review Panel

Attachments:      Personnel Complaint Report
                            Incident History
                            Warrant Abstract
                            Incident Card

WCA 5-1

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.