Documents › 2fdfa6eead7bdc0f0a0b360f9a01c917fcf25ddd:116-130

Monterey Park PD Internal Affairs Investigation: Officer Jeffery Sanchez

Agency records investigation reportagency investigation 2022-04-08 Monterey Park Police Department 15 pages (file pages 116–130) original file
About this document
Layer
agency record: part of a file an agency produced
Type as titled
ia investigation report (kind from doc_type)
Produced as
monterey-park-police-department/26-19 PRA Req_Redacted.pdf
File
2fdfa6eead7bdc0f0a0b360f9a01c917fcf25ddd application/pdf
Cases
agency:C-dcdf04ca7c · Jeffery Sanchez (record)

About: Jeffery Sanchez (case)

Page 14 · file page 129 larger image
Image of page 14; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

OPINIONS & CONCLUSIONS

Monterey Park Police Department Policy and Procedures section 319.5.9 (b.)

Unreasonable and unlawful force to a person encountered or a person under arrest.

In determining if the force used was reasonable under the totality of the circumstance, I reviewed department policy as well as case the law decision of Graham V. Conner. Officer Sanchez' force of striking [REDACTED] with a closed fist was reasonable and necessary to stop the assault against him, the fact that he was holding his flashlight was not intentional. Officer Sanchez didn't realize that he had his flashlight in his hand when he struck [REDACTED] The force used was not excessive. Graham V. Connor explains that 20/20 hindsight after the fact is not an objective test. Officer Sanchez' actions are judged based on the facts that are reasonably known to him at the time of the incident. His actions at that time were objectively reasonable, under the totality of the circumstance. The single strike to [REDACTED] was a reasonable use of force. Once the officer realized what he had done, he immediately re-evaluated his techniques and used control holds to restrain [REDACTED] [REDACTED] continued to assault the officers by kicking at them. This did not lead to another use of force against [REDACTED] other than physically restraining him. This was necessary to prevent [REDACTED] from continuing to kick at officers. The officers used a great deal of restraint while [REDACTED] continued to be assaultive, resistive, and making verbal threats to the officers.

Prior to the investigation, Lieutenant Villalobos completed an internal memorandum with his preliminary finding of Officer Sanchez use of force. This memorandum was written prior to him having all the facts and without him having enough time to review all the information. In his memo he stated that he believed the strike to [REDACTED] was unreasonable and unnecessary. I disagree with his findings. Lieutenant Villalobos stated that Officer Sanchez should have considered creating distance between himself and [REDACTED] once [REDACTED] started kicking him, taking another position of advantage such as kneeling next to [REDACTED] and using a leg restraint to prevent [REDACTED] from kicking his feet.

Penal code section 835a states that "A peace officer who makes or attempts to make an arrest need not retreat or desist from his efforts by reason of the resistance or threatened resistance of the person being arrested; nor shall such officer be deemed an aggressor or lose his right to self-defense by the use of reasonable force to effect the arrest or to prevent escape or to overcome resistance." Officer Sanchez force was in response to the attack from [REDACTED] He didn't have to, nor was he obligated to create distance in response to being kicked. After [REDACTED] was hit, Officer Sanchez did kneel next to [REDACTED] and with the assistance of Corporal Contreras and Officer Froussine, held and controlled [REDACTED] on the ground until paramedic responded to the scene.

Although [REDACTED] was struck by Officer Sanchez fist, while holding his flashlight, the intent was not to strike him with the flashlight. The intent was to strike him with his fist. It was unfortunate that he was holding his flashlight at the time of the punch. Officer Sanchez did not have time to switch his flashlight to his other hand prior to punching [REDACTED] Officer Sanchez didn't realize that he had his flashlight in his hand until after the

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.