Documents › 2bd9a649a8723d888045c769b60a1d63bb337cbd:468-484
691 - BR01_POST2403212_Adams Richard_ISF.pdf
About this document
- Layer
- packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
- Type as titled
- isf (kind from doc_type)
- File
- 2bd9a649a8723d888045c769b60a1d63bb337cbd application/pdf
- Cases
About: Richard Adams (case)
Page 12 · file page 479
larger image
Text: digital text layer
Investigative Summary and Recommendation
Richard Adams
Case Number POST2403212
Page 12
As noted earlier in section V, above, the Respondent appealed his termination and had
an SPB hearing on April 1-2, 2025. Administrative Law Judge Douglas Purdy presided.
In his Proposed Decision, which was later adopted in full by the SPB, Judge Prudy cited
Evidence Code 780 in determining credibility. That law provides that the trier of fact
may consider any matter that has any tendency in reason to prove or disprove the
truthfulness of testimony, including witness demeanor, character of testimony, extent of
witnesses ability to perceive, recollect or communicate any matter about which she or
he testifies.
Judge Purdy’s decision provided in part as follows, “[t]he video footage from the
doorbell camera was not consistent with consensual role-playing. [Respondent] lifted
[the Victim] and tossed her onto the front porch, where she landed on her back. That
action clearly could have resulted in serious injury to [the Victim], which makes it
unlikely that she willingly consented to it. [Respondent’s] demeanor in the footage
appeared angry and aggressive. [The Victim] appeared to be frightened and screamed
at [Respondent] several times to stop. [Respondent’s] testimony therefore was not
consistent with the video footage.” [Board Resolution and Order/Proposed Decision,
case 24-1576, pages 14 and 15].
When interviewed by the Division, the Respondent continued to maintain that the
doorbell video footage was nothing more than consensual role playing. In assessing
the Respondent’s credibility, the Division finds it implausible to believe the footage is
consensual role playing after watching the video numerous times. The Division’s
reasoning is based on the tone of voice and visible demeanor of the Respondent who
sounds and appears angry, and that of the Victim who sounds frightened and seems to
be protecting herself as she repeatedly tells the Respondent to stop.
Therefore, the Division finds the Respondent is not credible regarding his explanation
as to what occurred on the doorbell video.
The Division also finds that the clear and convincing evidence substantiated that
Respondent’s conduct amounted to acts that violate the law as described in
Commission Regulation 1205(a)(6), in that on July 13, 2023, the Respondent physically
harmed the Victim by forcibly throwing her to the ground outside their residence and
further dragging her on the ground by her ankles. This conduct was inconsistent with
the Respondent's obligation to uphold the law or respect the rights of members of the
public. The Division finds the Respondent’s act of violence upon the Victim not only
violated CHP’s internal policies, but also CA Penal Code sections 242 and 243(e)(1),
which confirms the Respondent’s unlawful conduct. In addition to violating the CHP’s
policies with regards to off-duty conduct, clear and convincing evidence exists that
Respondent violated California Penal Code section 13510.8(b)(6) and Commission
Regulation 1205(a)(6) – Acts That Violate the Law.
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.