Documents › 1a3828887c2a95668432b9349dd3427c52f4f2c3:1-1

Ventura PD Interview Transcript: Officer Emerson Mercado

Agency records interview transcriptagency investigation 2023-11-09 Ventura Police Department 1 page (file pages 1–1) original file
About this document
Layer
agency record: part of a file an agency produced
Type as titled
ia interview transcript (kind from doc_type)
Produced as
ventura-police-department/Mercado/2023-INT-0006 Mercado Interview.WMA
File
1a3828887c2a95668432b9349dd3427c52f4f2c3 video/x-ms-asf
Cases
agency:C-6cc5f1be02 · Emerson Mercado (record)

About: Emerson Mercado (case)

Page 1 · file page 1

This recording (video/x-ms-asf) won't play in a browser. Download it; its transcript is alongside.

Text: speech transcript (machine) machine transcript, speakers not labelled
  1. 0:00Okay, good morning. Today's date is November 9th, 2023, and by my clock I have 0-9-49 hours.
  2. 0:10The location of the interview is the Professional Standards Conference Room.
  3. 0:13Present to be interviewed is Officer Emerson Mercado, ID number 501.
  4. 0:17Correct.
  5. 0:18Your assignment on the date of the alleged occurrence was you were a traffic officer?
  6. 0:22Currently, yes.
  7. 0:23You are accompanied by your attorney, Robert Bauman.
  8. 0:26and I'm the primary investigator, Commander Sarah Hurd. Secondary investigator is Sergeant
  9. 0:31Turner Marchetti. I'm ID 354. He's ID 380. You are being interviewed as an accused employee.
  10. 0:38The nature of the allegation is that on October 10th, 2023, you informed Sergeant Marchetti that
  11. 0:44you were the suspect in a criminal investigation for insurance fraud and were under investigation
  12. 0:47by the California Department of Insurance. Our understanding is that it was submitted to the
  13. 0:52the DA's office for review. This interview pertains to potential criminal misconduct.
  14. 0:58Therefore, I'm going to advise you of your Miranda rights. You have the right to remain
  15. 1:01silent. Do you understand? Yes. Anything you say may be used against you in court. Do you
  16. 1:05understand? Yes. You have the right to the presence of an attorney before and during
  17. 1:08any questioning. Do you understand? Yes. If you cannot afford an attorney, one will be
  18. 1:12appointed for you free of charge before any questioning if you want. Do you understand?
  19. 1:15Yes. Do you want to talk about what happened? No. Okay.
  20. 1:23Emerson Mercado, I'm giving you a direct order to answer any and all questions asked of you in a truthful and accurate manner.
  21. 1:29Your failure to do so may be deemed insubordination and may result in administrative discipline up to and including termination of your employment with this agency.
  22. 1:37Do you understand?
  23. 1:37Yes.
  24. 1:38Will you now provide a statement?
  25. 1:39Yes.
  26. 1:40Okay, thank you.
  27. 1:40So I'm in charge of the investigation.
  28. 1:43If you guys need to take a break at any time, use the restroom, get a drink, you guys need to talk privately, just let me know.
  29. 1:48And within reason, we'll make that accommodation.
  30. 1:49So you obviously have a right to make a recording.
  31. 1:52I see your attorney's doing that and at the end of this whole thing you can have copies of any recordings that we have, okay?
  32. 1:59All right, so
  33. 2:02Basically at this point we
  34. 2:05We we got the information from you that you were under investigation for insurance fraud and we're
  35. 2:10Want to know exactly the circumstances of why and what happened so if you want to just kind of tell us the story that
  36. 2:15Yeah, so about a month ago October 10th. I received a voicemail from
  37. 2:20from a detective with the Department of Insurance.
  38. 2:24I don't recall his name offhand,
  39. 2:26but he left me a voicemail saying he was following up
  40. 2:28on an auto insurance claim that I had filed
  41. 2:31and asked that I call him back.
  42. 2:33I left the contact information, so I called him back.
  43. 2:37He reintroduced himself.
  44. 2:38He said that he was following up with an auto insurance claim
  45. 2:41from the insurance that I had at the time,
  46. 2:43which was Progressive.
  47. 2:46He said that they had submitted the claim to him
  48. 2:49for follow-up due to some discrepancy in the claim. He asked me if I
  49. 2:55remembered the claim itself. I told him that I did. He asked me, he just kind of
  50. 3:01went in asking me questions instead of allowing me to give a statement essentially. He asked me if I
  51. 3:08remembered who I spoke with. I know the two names of the two adjusters because
  52. 3:11he had told me but at the time I didn't remember. I still don't know
  53. 3:15which adjuster was which. I just know that one of them was Lisa and the
  54. 3:18the other one was Cheyenne. He asked me what my interactions were with each of
  55. 3:22them. I told him that I had submitted my claim through my app. I don't remember the day but
  56. 3:29I submitted the claim. About a day or two later I received a phone call from, I
  57. 3:34believe it's Cheyenne, was the one I spoke with first. He called me to just
  58. 3:38confirm the claim and set up an appointment for my vehicle to be looked
  59. 3:42at for an estimate through one of their body shops within their provider or
  60. 3:46through their network rather she set up the appointment body shop called me that
  61. 3:53day maybe the next day vehicle was taken in I got an estimate about a day after I
  62. 3:59got the estimate I received a phone call from who I believe was Lisa at that
  63. 4:05point she had told me that she was looking into the claim due to some
  64. 4:09discrepancy in the photos that I had attached to my claim originally online
  65. 4:15or on my app. She asked me if I knew what the discrepancy was. I told her I did not.
  66. 4:21At the time, I did not. She told me that the timeline that I had given in my claim did
  67. 4:27not match up to the timestamp on the photos. So the photos had a timestamp of a prior date
  68. 4:35to the collision. As soon as she told me that, she said that she'd be following up with it
  69. 4:41and that she would give me a call back at a later time.
  70. 4:45The vehicle that I was involved in a collision with
  71. 4:47was registered to me.
  72. 4:48It was under my insurance.
  73. 4:50But it's my sister's car.
  74. 4:51Essentially, she drives it 95% of the time.
  75. 4:56So I reached out to her.
  76. 4:58I asked her if she knew why there was that discrepancy.
  77. 5:02At that point, she came forward and told me
  78. 5:04she had crashed the car about a month prior.
  79. 5:07Didn't tell me about it
  80. 5:08because she thought I would take the car away from her
  81. 5:11given that it was in my name I helped her buy it and that the photo she had sent me were photos
  82. 5:17that she had taken when she tc'd at that point I called back Cheyenne because Lisa called me from
  83. 5:24a block number she didn't answer I left her a voicemail I said hey I have information regarding
  84. 5:29my claim I know what the discrepancy is if you can just give me a call back I can explain it to you
  85. 5:35she didn't call me back so I called her a second time still no answer I left her a second voicemail
  86. 5:40explaining to her that there was a prior TC that I was unaware about and that
  87. 5:45because of this discrepancy that I needed to terminate my claim. I didn't
  88. 5:48want to follow through with the claim any longer. I never received a
  89. 5:54phone call back from her or Lisa. I'd say about two days after that I checked my
  90. 6:01Progressive app and saw from the home page it always has your open claims and
  91. 6:05closed claims. I'd seen that they had closed the claim, so I figured that that was the it
  92. 6:13because I didn't hear anything. About a week or so later, I received a notice in the mail from
  93. 6:19the insurance saying that because of the discrepancy in that claim that they would be
  94. 6:25canceling my insurance. They gave me an end date of when they would cancel my policy. I don't recall
  95. 6:32I do recall the date. However, I do recall that it was about a week and a half, two weeks after the ending of my billing cycle.
  96. 6:41Originally, I had told Sergeant Marquet that I had received a check for the excess of my premium.
  97. 6:47That was incorrect. They never charged me for my premium at the end of my billing cycle since the end of the, when they were terminating my policy.
  98. 6:55Like I said, it was about a week and a half after.
  99. 6:57They never charged me for my premium.
  100. 6:59They just canceled the policy, and I never heard anything after that
  101. 7:02until about a month ago when this detective reached out to me.
  102. 7:07Okay.
  103. 7:07So I just want to make sure I understand the full scope of it.
  104. 7:10So is your sister, is she a minor?
  105. 7:13No, she's 19.
  106. 7:15Okay, and does she live with you?
  107. 7:16She does not.
  108. 7:17Okay, so she normally drives the car.
  109. 7:19Correct.
  110. 7:20And you drive the car on occasion?
  111. 7:22Occasionally.
  112. 7:22So she's my primary child care, so she comes over often.
  113. 7:27Um, sometimes if I ride my personal motorcycle to my mom's house, um, I'll drive her car
  114. 7:32home because I live out in Fillmore, which is really super dark.
  115. 7:35I don't like driving at night or riding my motorcycle at night rather.
  116. 7:38Um, so that night was actually a night that I had taken her car home from my mom's house.
  117. 7:44When you say that night, you mean the night that you got, the night that I had hit, whatever
  118. 7:47it was, I hit on the freeway.
  119. 7:49I believe it to be an animal, but I don't, I don't know for sure.
  120. 7:53So yeah, what happened on that?
  121. 7:54So you're driving home and what happened?
  122. 7:55Yeah.
  123. 7:56So I'm driving home.
  124. 7:56I'm like, I don't know, I'm probably about three miles away from the city of Fillmore,
  125. 8:02so kind of in the rural areas right before.
  126. 8:06Number one lane, I'm probably going about 72, maybe 75,
  127. 8:11and I just hear a loud thud, and I feel something along the passenger side of the vehicle, essentially.
  128. 8:19Pulled off, I looked, I didn't see an animal or a person in the roadway.
  129. 8:24Looked around, didn't see anything, there was no other cars.
  130. 8:26So I went home, no, I went home, next day, next day, two days later, I don't recall which
  131. 8:35one, but I had driven back to my mom's, I took the car back, I went to go pick up my
  132. 8:39motorcycle, saw the damage to the car, at that point, where was the damage to the car?
  133. 8:46No, so the damage to the car was along the passenger side, up near the front bumper,
  134. 8:52and it went back a little bit towards the front passenger wheel.
  135. 8:57Part of the bumper, though, still the front bumper.
  136. 9:00And that's the first time you noticed the damage?
  137. 9:02That was the first time I had noticed the damage.
  138. 9:03You didn't notice it when you got out of the car?
  139. 9:05No.
  140. 9:05It was dark and I didn't really, like I said, I didn't really look.
  141. 9:08I was more looking for a body or what I hit more than anything was my concern.
  142. 9:15At that point, I left the car there.
  143. 9:17I went back, went about my day.
  144. 9:19I don't know what I did after that, but I just went about my day back home.
  145. 9:25A few days later, well, that same day I reached out to my sister.
  146. 9:29I said, hey, you know what, I'll file a claim with the insurance.
  147. 9:31Just send me photos of the damage so I can submit it in my app.
  148. 9:36She sends me photos.
  149. 9:38I didn't think anything of it.
  150. 9:40I just took the photos.
  151. 9:41I saved them, filed my claim, attached the photos, and then, like I said, after I filed the claim a few days later,
  152. 9:48I was contacted, and they confirmed the claim that they got it, that they got the photos.
  153. 9:54And then everything else kind of fell in after that.
  154. 9:57So when you went to get into the car before you drove it, did you ever notice any damage?
  155. 10:02I didn't look.
  156. 10:04Did you not go on that side of the car or what?
  157. 10:07I backed the car in the driveway, so I get in on the driver's side.
  158. 10:11So I didn't bother to look.
  159. 10:13Okay.
  160. 10:13What was the date and time of the collision that you were involved in?
  161. 10:18Roughly.
  162. 10:19Beginning of December.
  163. 10:20I don't recall the exact date.
  164. 10:25Of December?
  165. 10:26Of December of last year.
  166. 10:28And then how much time passed before you reported the claim?
  167. 10:33I don't recall.
  168. 10:34It was a few days.
  169. 10:36It wasn't more than a few days.
  170. 10:39So this is all you're thinking in your mind, I'm guessing, when you came to Trenner.
  171. 10:44When they called you, I guess, on the 10th.
  172. 10:46you're like thinking this is long long past like yeah it was almost it was almost a year ago i mean
  173. 10:51i didn't heard anything like i said i saw that they had canceled the claim initially i understood
  174. 10:56why they terminated my policy but since i didn't hear any follow-up from either of them after
  175. 11:01leaving them a couple voicemails i just i didn't think anything of it at the time until i received
  176. 11:07the voicemail from the detective did you get any email or mail correspondence after your cancellation
  177. 11:13nothing they just the only correspondence I got in the mail was them
  178. 11:17telling me they were terminating my policy that was it I never heard
  179. 11:20anything else after after that that was the only thing and then your sister did
  180. 11:24she tell you what she hit or what her collision so she believes that she hit
  181. 11:28an animal she thinks it was like a little coyote on her way to work about a
  182. 11:33month prior it was like early November ish when you is where does she live
  183. 11:39person where you live so she lives in oakview and then i live out in fillmore
  184. 11:45and at that time just to kind of close the gap did she take pictures of the damage yeah so the
  185. 11:50photos that she had sent me were actually photos that she had taken the morning of her collision
  186. 11:55so she she was on her way to work she works at or she used to work at starbucks harvard
  187. 12:00on her way in she was an opener so she was on her way in four or five o'clock in the morning
  188. 12:05still dark out and she hit what she believed to be a coyote but she doesn't
  189. 12:10know for sure she just she just hit an animal. How much before your collision
  190. 12:15did that occur? I believe it was about a month maybe three weeks. And has she
  191. 12:21talked to the Department of Insurance? No and I asked him I was like do you want
  192. 12:26to contact her? He didn't want to speak with her.
  193. 12:33um and then she was on her way to work um but she never tells you because she's afraid you'll
  194. 12:38take her car away right correct um but she did take photos she did do you know when she took
  195. 12:43the photos that same morning okay did she say why she took photos i believe she shared them
  196. 12:49with my mom so she told my mom about the collision but they never told me about it
  197. 12:56Okay. What kind of car is it?
  198. 12:58A 2021 Volkswagen Jetta. Not 100% of the year, but I think it's a 2021.
  199. 13:06Okay. What color?
  200. 13:07Dark gray.
  201. 13:10Okay. And then how bad was the damage?
  202. 13:13It was minor. It was just the bumper where it attaches to the front quarter panel had fallen off.
  203. 13:20and then the black like I guess like the grill part was plastic that cracked in
  204. 13:27half that was it it was very minor so like looking at the car from a distance
  205. 13:31would you notice it no I don't think so I mean you'd have to really know where
  206. 13:38it's at to see it was pretty minor. Okay, got anything else right now?
  207. 13:51Have you thought of anywhere anywhere else or if there's anything else
  208. 13:56that will just help corroborate your story you know to kind of shore up their
  209. 13:59their investigation, get it done, and move on?
  210. 14:05No. I mean, I
  211. 14:07guess, no, I don't think so. What? I mean, there's no,
  212. 14:11my drive home, like I said, it's pretty much just orchard and farmland, so
  213. 14:15there's not really anything that
  214. 14:19could place me somewhere, essentially.
  215. 14:24I have cameras on my house, but those get
  216. 14:27get removed every 30 days normally. I delete them every day naturally.
  217. 14:36When you were driving home and you hit what you thought was an animal, you said it was
  218. 14:40the beginning of December. Do you remember, like, what time of night it was or what time
  219. 14:43of day?
  220. 14:43It was nighttime. It had to have been sometime after 9 or 10. It was relatively late.
  221. 14:52What's been your sister's response to this? You know, you don't have to get into details
  222. 14:56tell some personal stuff but uh she's afraid she's upset she knows that because she didn't
  223. 15:02tell me that that i'm now doing this and i'm looking at potentially getting in trouble i
  224. 15:08could potentially lose my job um so she's she's shooken up about it because she feels responsible
  225. 15:13i mean she's a 19 year old girl she doesn't know any better um but yeah she's she's pretty
  226. 15:18she's pretty shooken up about it so just so that we have everything out on the table
  227. 15:23Did you commit insurance fraud?
  228. 15:26No.
  229. 15:26Did you make a claim?
  230. 15:27No.
  231. 15:28Did you know the damage was there prior to your hitting something?
  232. 15:31No.
  233. 15:31Okay.
  234. 15:33I mean, you're a traffic investigator, so do you feel you committed any crime in this scenario?
  235. 15:38No.
  236. 15:38My God.
  237. 15:42That's all I have, unless there's anything you wanted to add on the record or ask of your client.
  238. 15:45No.
  239. 15:45I think, yeah, as long as you guys are good on the timeline, because I know when I first talked,
  240. 15:49it took me a second to kind of figure out the timeline on the photos.
  241. 15:52I didn't understand, I guess.
  242. 15:53Because the photos were taken before, and then when Officer Ricardo requested the photos,
  243. 15:59she just automatically sent photos, but you assumed she had just taken brand new photos of the craft.
  244. 16:04So you asked her to take photos, but she just sent you the ones she already had on her phone?
  245. 16:08I asked her to send me photos.
  246. 16:09Okay, I mean, right.
  247. 16:10But I didn't, again, I didn't think anything of it.
  248. 16:14I was just saying, just send me photos of the damage was all I told you.
  249. 16:16You didn't go looking at the metadata before uploading it?
  250. 16:19Exactly.
  251. 16:19I just sent them and I just tagged them, or uploaded them, rather.
  252. 16:24And you might have said this, and I apologize if I just don't have it written down,
  253. 16:27but you said it was about a month before is when she had her accident?
  254. 16:31Yeah, it was somewhere around there, about three weeks, three to four weeks.
  255. 16:36Okay.
  256. 16:36Is the estimate, well, first off, how much is the estimate for,
  257. 16:41and did they separate the two areas of damage that look like it's probably her incident versus yours?
  258. 16:47The insurance.
  259. 16:49for the estimate no they just they gave me one estimate for it initially I don't recall the
  260. 16:56amount I think it was somewhere about 1500 1800 somewhere in there okay they had to replace
  261. 17:02pretty much the bumper and there was like a little bit of a transfer okay I guess what I'm gonna do
  262. 17:11is is there independent damage it's clearly from your sister's incident versus yours or is it all
  263. 17:16all the same spot no it's all it was all well i and that's the issue that i'm coming across is i
  264. 17:22don't know i just saw the damage there bumper was hanging off and that it's cracked so i don't know
  265. 17:27how much of it was from hers or how much of it was from mine like i said i felt more of mine
  266. 17:32along the passenger side along the wheel so if the damage was there it's likely that maybe i ran
  267. 17:38something but i don't i don't know for sure i don't know for sure i'm sure you've thought about
  268. 17:43this a lot so now that you've thought about it are you thinking it's more
  269. 17:47possible that you actually didn't strike anything when you hit that maybe you
  270. 17:51just ran something over it's possible that I just ran something but I don't I
  271. 17:54don't know for sure like I said I felt most of it in the front passenger side
  272. 17:58under the wheel but again I can't so you heard a thump but you didn't do you know
  273. 18:03I feel like I felt it you felt I felt it yeah did you feel it like you can kind
  274. 18:06of tell if your car kind of raises did that happen or you just yeah so I felt I
  275. 18:10I felt like an initial impact, and it was more just like a jerk of the wheel.
  276. 18:13It wasn't, like I said, it wasn't significant to the point to where, like, the car had gone up or anything, but I did feel it.
  277. 18:21But you never saw the animal?
  278. 18:22No, I never saw anything.
  279. 18:24And that occurred on the 126th?
  280. 18:27Yeah, so eastbound 126th, like, going towards Fillmore, so I was going home.
  281. 18:32Whereabouts? Like, where, near what, do you remember?
  282. 18:34It was probably just past, there's a nursery right before town.
  283. 18:41I believe it's called Mejia's Nurse Street, but I'm not 100% sure.
  284. 18:45And that's, on the portion that's not like freeway, it's more like the highway portion that's not, it doesn't have a divider, like a solid divider?
  285. 18:54No, no. It's an undivided highway from, just past Santa Paula all the way to Fillmore.
  286. 19:01Right.
  287. 19:01At Halleck.
  288. 19:02So you're somewhere between Santa Paula and Fillmore?
  289. 19:05Correct. Just east of Santa Paula.
  290. 19:12Did your sister say where her collision occurred?
  291. 19:15I just know it was on her way to work, so somewhere on the 33, but I don't know where exactly.
  292. 19:19Okay, and she lives in Oakview.
  293. 19:21Yeah, and the same thing, it's a two-lane, well, it's a one-lane undivided up until you get to Foster Park,
  294. 19:31and then it becomes a split with the center median all the way until you get to the 101 overpass.
  295. 19:38Um, I know you said she does your child care.
  296. 19:39I'm just trying to wrap my head around.
  297. 19:40So you were at their house.
  298. 19:42Were you picking up your child, or what was?
  299. 19:43No, we were there, I believe I was there for my mom's birthday,
  300. 19:47because her birthday is the beginning of the month.
  301. 19:49I think we were having dinner there, and then I had gone home after that.
  302. 19:53Was it just you in the car by yourself?
  303. 19:55Yeah, it was just me.
  304. 19:55My wife had already gone home with our kids.
  305. 19:58Separate car.
  306. 19:58Yeah.
  307. 19:59Okay.
  308. 20:01And then did your sister say whether or not she had someone in the car at the time of her collision?
  309. 20:04She did not.
  310. 20:05It was just her going to work.
  311. 20:06Going to work.
  312. 20:06That was it, yeah.
  313. 20:08Okay.
  314. 20:09I think that's all I have.
  315. 20:10That's all I have.
  316. 20:11Okay.
  317. 20:11We'll end the interview.
  318. 20:12Thank you.
  319. 20:13All right.
  320. 20:13Thank you.
  321. 20:14Good night.
  322. 20:14Good night.

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.