Documents › 1673b26d637462e91d4484f0c372851e40446fc8:719-741
637 - BR01_POST2402562_Montalvo_Armando_ISF_Final (1).pdf
About this document
- Layer
- packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
- Type as titled
- isf (kind from doc_type)
- File
- 1673b26d637462e91d4484f0c372851e40446fc8 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Armando R. Montalvo (case)
Page 22 · file page 740
larger image
Text: digital text layer
20
Investigative Summary and Recommendation
Armando Montalvo
Case Number POST2402562
• Lieutenant Buffong noted he agreed with Sergeant Raphael’s assess-
ment and noted, “…the force used during the incident does not appear
reasonable or within the framework of our current use of force depart-
ment policy.” 6
• Commander Wilson noted in his recommendations and conclusions in re-
view of the Use of Force Report, “Based on the video footage and written
reports included in this analysis, I concur with the findings of Lt. Buffong
and Sgt. Raphael and deem this use of force to be unreasonable and
outside of department policy.”7
• The Orange County Sheriff’s Department sustained the allegation that
the force used by Respondent was unreasonable and Respondent re-
ceived discipline in the form of a 40-hour suspension.
Based on the abovementioned facts, the force used by Respondent was not pro-
portionate to INMATE’s resistive behavior and not objectively reasonable. Re-
spondent could have engaged in less intrusive and reasonable alternatives to
punching INMATE over 28 times without pause and slamming INMATE’s head
into the concrete. Respondent admitted that he continued to utilize punches, an
injury level use of force that was not effective. Respondent could not identify a
goal he had when he slammed INMATE’s head into the ground. Respondent
also admitted he used a technique that was not taught when he slammed IN-
MATE’s head into the floor while lying prone. Respondent admitted during his
administrative interview that he got tunnel vision and used unreasonable force for
the level of resistance INMATE displayed. Respondent also admitted that he
failed to allow INMATE to comply with any instructions, instead repeatedly punch-
ing INMATE and then slamming INMATE’s head into the ground.
Therefore, clear and convincing evidence exists that the force used by Respond-
ent was excessive in that Respondent punched INMATE twenty-eight (28) times
and slammed INMATE’s head onto the concrete and was unreasonable and ex-
cessive based on the level of resistance offered by INMATE.
VI.
Supporting Evidence and Documentation
• Attachment A – OCSD Report 24-009233
• Attachment B – OCSD Use of Force Report 24-009233
• Attachment C –Video #1 24-009233
• Attachment D- Video #2 24-009233
• Attachment E- Handheld Video 24-009233
• Attachment F – INMATE Use of Force Interview
• Attachment G – Respondent Interview
6 Attachment B- OCSD Use of Force Report 24-009233 Page 8 Lt. Conclusions/ Recommendations
7 Attachment B- OCSD Use of Force Report 24-009233 Page 8 Commander Recommendations and Conclusions
740
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.