Documents › 0f82b840829ca1b3bc896b97ad7531b99d628b53:1-28

LAPD Chief of Police Memorandum Regarding Officer-Involved Shooting FID No. 064-21

POST board correspondencecorrespondence and logs 2022-10-05 28 pages (file pages 1–28) original file
About this document
Layer
attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
Type as titled
internal department memo (kind from doc_type)
File
0f82b840829ca1b3bc896b97ad7531b99d628b53 application/pdf
Cases
POST 2311370 · Jose Zavala (filed under case)
POST 2311373 · Julio Quintanilla (filed under case)

About: Jose Zavala (case), Julio Quintanilla (case)

Page 25 · file page 25 larger image
Image of page 25; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

The Honorable Board of Police Commissioners

Page 25

3.2

of the citizens nearby. While the Board considered Officer Zavala's perception, they noted that the investigation did not support his belief of the imminent deadly threat posed by Victim. Although Officer Zavala may have feared for his life, his partner's life, and the lives of the citizens, the Board opined that his fear was predicated on the likelihood of future harm, not an imminent deadly threat. Based on the BWV footage, the Board opined that Victim did not have the apparent intent to harm Officer Zavala when the OIS occurred. The Board also opined that he did not have the apparent intent or the opportunity to harm the citizens as officers were controlling pedestrian traffic. Based on the totality of the circumstances, the Board opined that Officer Zavala's use of lethal force, all three rounds, was not objectively reasonable, proportional, or necessary.

Regarding Officer Quintanilla, the Board was again critical of the perceived threat posed by Victim and opined that the investigation did not support his assertion of an imminent deadly threat. Although Officer Quintanilla may have feared for his life, his partner's life, and the lives of the citizens, they believed his fear was also predicated on the likelihood of future harm, not an imminent deadly threat. Based on the BWV footage, the Board opined that Victim did not have the apparent intent to harm Officer Quintanilla when the OIS occurred. While the Board considered Officer Quintanilla's statements regarding the imminent threat Victim posed to his family and pedestrians, the Board opined that he did not have the apparent intent or the opportunity to harm them as officers were controlling pedestrian traffic and Victim's family was east of his location. Based on the totality of the circumstances, the Board opined that Officer Quintanilla's use of lethal force was not objectively reasonable, proportional, or necessary.

Based on the totality of the circumstances, the UOFRB determined, and I concur, that an officer with similar training and experience as Officers Zavala and Quintanilla would not reasonably believe that the use of lethal force was proportional, objectively reasonable, or necessary.

Therefore, I find Officer Zavala and Quintanilla's Use of Lethal Force, all rounds, to be Out of Policy, Administrative Disapproval.

Medical Treatment/Rendering Aid – At approximately 1711:15 hours, the arrest team approached Victim and took him into custody. At approximately 1711:33 hours, officers handcuffed Victim, placed him on his right side, and checked him for injuries; Sergeant broadcast a Code Four and requested the response of the RA unit. At approximately 1712:15 hours, Officer Quintanilla directed Officer 2 to retrieve his medical kit from the trunk of his vehicle. As Officer 2 attempted to locate the medical kit in the trunk, FF/PM C. Shubsda and M. Farris, arrived at the scene. Officer Quintanilla advised paramedics that Victim had gunshot wounds, directing their attention to his chest. Victim was treated at the scene and transported to LAC+USCMC where he was treated by Doctor B. Knipp for gunshot wounds to the neck, chest, and torso. At 1809 hours, Victim succumbed to his injuries and was pronounced deceased.

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.