Documents › 0b59e47e939063f8938332267911cbb97f962b8a:996-1032

438 - BR3_POST2300017_Matejcek_Paul_REDACTED.pdf

POST board investigation reportagency investigation 2024-10-17 37 pages (file pages 996–1032) original file
About this document
Layer
packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
Type as titled
case_attachment (kind from hand)
File
0b59e47e939063f8938332267911cbb97f962b8a application/pdf
Cases
POST 2300017 · Paul Matejcek (packet item)

About: Paul Matejcek (case)

Page 35 · file page 1030 larger image
Image of page 35; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

thereafter, to obtain a spit hood and place it on Ms. [V1] to prevent being spit on by her, even though all BPD patrol vehicles are equipped with spit hoods and BPD officers are authorized to use them in such circumstances.29 Further, immediately following the kick, Officer Matejcek is shown on the Franson body-worn camera video searching Ms. [V1] for about four minutes at the hood of his car, often placing his face within one to two feet of Ms. [V1] head without registering any concern that Ms. [V1] might spit at him.30

Officer Flynn and Officer Franson did not have the same concerns about Ms. [V1] standing up as Officer Matejcek did, which was evinced on Officer Franson's body-worn camera video when neither of them moved discernably at all when Ms. [V1] started standing up. Officer Flynn and Officer Franson each unhesitatingly stated during their interviews that they were surprised by Officer Matejcek kicking Ms. [V1] in the manner that he did, and each believed Officer Matejcek's kick of Ms. [V1] to have been unreasonable under the circumstances. Officer Flynn and Officer Franson also offered a number of feasible, reasonable, and less intrusive alternatives to Officer Matejcek's kick that were available at the time, such as more verbal commands, maintaining distance to further observe Ms. [V1] and her intentions, using a control hold or grabbing her arm, and either pulling Ms. [V1] back down into a seated position, or escorting her to one of the nearby patrol vehicles.31

Sergeant Nance—a defensive tactics instructor at BPD for over 20 years, the lead BPD defensive tactics instructor for the last three years, an accomplished outside agency instructor in defensive tactics, arrest and control, and uses of force, and a published author and editor for noted law enforcement publications about those subjects—substantially and independently agreed with the observations of Officers Flynn and Franson, including their belief that there were feasible, less intrusive options to control Ms. [V1] at the time. Sergeant Nance, after viewing the video showing Officer Matejcek's kick of Ms. [V1] several times, reading Officer Matejcek's report, and being provided Officer Matejcek's stated reasoning for his kick of Ms. [V1] also opined that Officer Matejcek's kick was unreasonable under the circumstances, "Because there was other officers present. There was no imminent threat. She's handcuffed. She did not lunge at the officers, although the officer may well believe she might, it did not appear that she made any attempt to close distance." Sergeant Nance added that he did not believe Officer Matejcek intended to cause injury to Ms. [V1] and that it appeared that Officer Matejcek intended to kick Ms. [V1] in order to push her back to the ground.32


29 Exhibits 16, 17.

30 Exhibit 1, 9:16-14:03 (end of video). Ms. [V1], still without a spit hood, later spit on CSO Alan Sheffield at the Martinez Detention facility. (Exhibit 3 (CSO Sheffield's supplemental report).)

31 Exhibit 15, Section 300.3.2(j).

32 The Investigator concurs with Sergeant Nance on this point and does not find that Officer Matejcek was attempting to injure Ms. [V1]. Instead, consistent with Officer Matejcek's explanation that he was effectively trying to topple Ms. [V1] and "wasn't trying to field goal

Confidential Report
City of Brentwood

33

1030

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.