438 - BR3_POST2300017_Matejcek_Paul_REDACTED.pdf
About this document
- Layer
- packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
- Type as titled
- case_attachment (kind from hand)
- File
- 0b59e47e939063f8938332267911cbb97f962b8a application/pdf
- Cases
About: Paul Matejcek (case)
summary of Officer Matejcek's stated rationale for kicking Ms. [V1] in the manner that he did:
[Matejcek] thought that [V1] was either going to jump forward at him if she stood up, spit at them or run away, which might require them to tackle her causing more injury. So he said that he wanted to push her off balance with his foot back into the shed door and onto her butt, if possible, but did not want to go hands on because he did not want to be spit on.
The Investigator then asked if Sergeant Nance believed that Officer Matejcek's kick was reasonable force under the circumstances. Sergeant Nance responded:
No . . . Because there was other officers present. There was no imminent threat. She's handcuffed. She's not at risk of escaping. She's not going to outrun those three officers handcuffed. She did not lunge at the officers, although the officer may well believe she might, it did not appear that she made any attempt to close distance. Based on those reasons, yeah, it seems like it was not a reasonable use of force.
The Investigator relayed to Sergeant Nance that Officers Franson and Flynn each believed there were less intrusive options available at the time to secure Ms. [V1] including use of a control hold and sitting her back on the ground or bringing her to a nearby patrol vehicle, or maintaining their distance and seeing what Ms. [V1] did. Sergeant Nance agreed that each of those less intrusive options was reasonable under the circumstances.
Sergeant Nance added: ". . . it does not appear to me as though the kick was delivered with the intent of causing injury or diminishing the suspect's capacity to fight back. I do believe he kicked her in order to push her back to the ground." Sergeant Nance believed Officer Matejcek's kick might have been more reasonable than it was if Ms. [V1] had not been handcuffed, but "would still likely be unreasonable in my opinion."
V. CREDIBILITY ASSESSMENTS
In connection with determining the facts alleged, and consistent with EEOC guidelines, the Investigator assessed the credibility of each witness by evaluating the witness's demeanor, potential bias or motivation to be untruthful, ability to recall information, the specificity of the information provided, the consistency of statements with a witness's prior statements and/or the statements of other witnesses, the inherent plausibility of witness statements, and, in some cases, the past record of a witness.
The Investigator found each witness to be forthright, honest, and credible.
Officer Matejcek seemed to sincerely believe his use-of-force was reasonable under the circumstances. While the other witnesses unanimously disagreed with Officer Matejcek's opinion about the force he used, and the findings below conclude that his use-of-force was not reasonable, the Investigator does not impute an intention by Officer Matejcek to purposefully overstate his perception of the threat presented by Ms. [V1], the nature of his relevant training, or any of the circumstances that led to his use-of-force.
Confidential Report
City of Brentwood
28
1025
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.