Documents › 0b59e47e939063f8938332267911cbb97f962b8a:968-993
438 - BR1_POST2300017_Matejcek_Paul_POST2300017_Matejcek_ISF_Sherburne_FINAL.pdf
About this document
- Layer
- packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
- Type as titled
- isf (kind from doc_type)
- File
- 0b59e47e939063f8938332267911cbb97f962b8a application/pdf
- Cases
About: Paul Matejcek (case)
Page 19 · file page 986
larger image
Text: digital text layer
Investigative Summary and Findings
Paul Matejcek (Respondent)
Case Number POST2300017
Page 19 of 26
she spit, kicked, and bit officers.64 Respondent stated during his appeal hearing that
he kicked Victim 1 because he knew she spit at officers in the past and he “used [his]
foot to keep [himself] as far away from her as [he] could, instead of getting my hands
close to her and pushing her back down to the ground.”65 I did not find Respondent’s
statements to be credible about the risk level Victim 1 posed. These statements are
post hoc rationalizations to justify his actions and stand in contrast to Franson’s and
Flynn’s statements about their perspectives at the time of the incident. Kicking Victim 1
brought Respondent closer to her and there was no indication in the previous eight to
ten minutes of his contact with Victim 1 that she acted in any manner that would
indicate she was going to spit at him.
Franson stated his perspective on the lack of risk Victim 1 posed:
Well, first off she's handcuffed. She's a fairly small person, that's comparing her
to me. Officer Matejcek's size is different than mine [footnote 2 omitted], it's
different than Flynn's, he's smaller than both of us as far as height ... Yeah, so
comparing size, the fact she's handcuffed, I believe that she had been pat
searched at that point, so there's no concern. I mean, maybe biting, but she
wasn't showing us that as an indicator that she might bite us, or spitting, there
was none of that going on. It was clearly just way too far, as far as force goes,
for that. Like you said, grabbing an arm, verbal commands to light touch, to
maybe a control hold, would be appropriate under those circumstances, from
what I recall at the time of that incident.66
Likewise, Flynn stated during his internal affairs interview that Victim 1 did not
pose a threat of violence: “No, just the same, ‘you guys are pigs. You guys are this,
you guys are that.’”67 Flynn also stated that Victim 1 was not a flight risk: “No. I
thought the worst we’d have to do is maybe take a couple running steps to catch her if
she tried to run since she was in handcuffs.”68
Respondent could have engaged in less intrusive and reasonable alternatives to
kicking Victim 1. As Flynn and Franson said during their IA interviews, these options
included additional “verbal commands, maintaining distance to further observe [Victim
1] and her intentions, using a control hold or grabbing her arm, and either pulling
64 Attachment H (Respondent IA Interview Transcript at 69).
65 Attachment C (Hearing Officer’s Recommendation at 7 (12/12/2023)). Compare Attachment H
(Respondent IA Interview Transcript at 70) (“Yeah. So that would mean I would have to bring my face
closer to hers. Right? And I know that she spits, which she eventually did, and that's why I didn't want to
use my hands and just simply grab her and take her to the car.”).
66 Attachment A (Brentwood Police Department IA Report 22-07 at 9-10 (6/29/2022)). Respondent’s
statement about Victim 1’s size is similarly incredible. He stated her weight was “’closer to 170, 180.’”
Attachment A (Brentwood Police Department IA Report 22-07 at 16 (6/29/2022)). In fact, Respondent
had not pat-searched Victim 1. Attachment H (Respondent IA Interview Transcript at 32).
67 Attachment I (Flynn IA Interview Transcript at 20).
68 Attachment I (Flynn IA Interview Transcript at 21).
986
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.