Documents › 0b59e47e939063f8938332267911cbb97f962b8a:968-993
438 - BR1_POST2300017_Matejcek_Paul_POST2300017_Matejcek_ISF_Sherburne_FINAL.pdf
About this document
- Layer
- packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
- Type as titled
- isf (kind from doc_type)
- File
- 0b59e47e939063f8938332267911cbb97f962b8a application/pdf
- Cases
About: Paul Matejcek (case)
Page 16 · file page 983
larger image
Text: digital text layer
Investigative Summary and Findings
Paul Matejcek (Respondent)
Case Number POST2300017
Page 16 of 26
the scene and faced with the same circumstances as Respondent, Flynn’s and
Franson’s actions – or lack thereof – are as equally significant to understand the level
of resistance and threat, Victim 1 posed under the totality of the circumstances the
officers faced. Neither Flynn nor Franson stated the force used by Respondent was
reasonable. In fact, immediately after Respondent kicked Victim 1, both Flynn and
Franson stated that they were surprised by the level of force used given the lack of
resistance.
While Respondent stated during his internal affairs interview that Victim 1 was
resisting,41 the clear and convincing evidence substantiated that Victim 1 did not
objectively pose a threat and was not resisting. When Victim 1 attempted to rise from a
seated position, Respondent was not faced with a split-second decision about how to
respond to a threat. This is apparent from the initial contact the officers had with Victim
1, as Victim 1 consistently did not display indicators of resistance, threat, or escape.
For example, the handcuffing process was relatively straightforward.
Respondent’s BWC showed that, from the time she exited the shed to the time
Respondent handcuffed her, Respondent had effective control over Victim 1 and that
she did not resist the handcuffing process.42 Officers ordered Victim 1 to sit down
several times and when ordered to put her hands behind her back, although she
questioned why,43 she did not resist Respondent’s physical efforts to enforce
commands to sit down or place her hands behind her back.44
The fact that Respondent was the only officer who was physically in contact with
Victim 1 also illustrated her lack of resistance at this early stage of the contact and the
officers’ belief that Victim 1 was not a safety threat. After Victim 1 sat down, Flynn
immediately started to explore the area and left his cover position from which he stood
ready to assist Respondent if he required assistance in controlling Victim 1.45 Although
Franson provided light to Respondent and continued to stand ready to assist
Respondent while Flynn entered the shed, he did not have physical contact with Victim
1.
After she was seated, Respondent noticed that Victim 1 had items in her hand.
Respondent ordered Victim 1 to drop what she was holding.46 Respondent shook her
hands and she immediately dropped the items in her hand without any attempt to
41 Attachment H (Respondent IA Interview Transcript at 67).
42 Attachment L (Respondent BWC at 5:32:23 AM – 5:32:32 AM); Attachment K (Franson BWC at
5:32:23 AM – 5:32:32 AM).
43 I cannot reasonably find that Victim 1’s questions and that officers had to order her several times to sit
down constituted even passive resistance. At best, Victim 1 appeared bewildered, although lucid.
44 Attachment L (Respondent BWC at 5:32:23 AM - 5:32:34 AM); Attachment K (Franson BWC at
5:32:23 AM - 5:32:34 AM).
45 Attachment L (Respondent BWC at 5:32:37 AM); Attachment K (Franson BWC at 5:32:37 AM).
46 Attachment L (Respondent BWC at 5:32:48AM); Attachment K (Franson BWC at 5:32:48 AM).
983
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.