Documents › 0b59e47e939063f8938332267911cbb97f962b8a:255-409

434 - BR3_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Redacted_Attachment_B.pdf

POST board investigation reportagency investigation 2024-10-17 155 pages (file pages 255–409) original file
About this document
Layer
packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
Type as titled
case_attachment (kind from hand)
File
0b59e47e939063f8938332267911cbb97f962b8a application/pdf
Cases
POST 2303451 · James Mutuku (packet item)

About: James Mutuku (case)

Page 132 · file page 386 larger image
Image of page 132; its text is alongside
Text: digital text layer
Administrative Investigation: PC2211047 / Hostile Work Environment Claim                                 
Page 132 of 155 
I explained I also looked at who could have been in the station at the time the flyers were 
printed, because after 4:00 pm, dayshift would have likely gone home.  He agreed and said, 
“Yeah, the majority of them, yeah.”201 
 
I told him I pulled Telestaff and GPS records to see who might have been at the station at the 
time the flyers were printed.  Telestaff only showed two officers, Pattison and Cappelen that 
held over and neither of them were mentioned by anyone interviewed.  GPS records only 
showed two units at the station at the time the flyers were printed.  (One of these units was J. 
Mutuku; the other was Sergeant Tanner Paes who was not mentioned by anyone interviewed 
in this investigation.)  I told him there weren’t many people at the station that would have had 
an opportunity to print the flyers.  He replied, “Okay.” 
 
I told J. Mutuku I knew from personal experience how hard it was at times to work with your 
spouse.  I could see why he would be frustrated and I didn’t understand why he never 
reported 
 for not backing his wife on calls.  I told him I just wanted him to be honest. 
 
J. Mutuku replied, “I understand what you’re saying. I understand the evidence you’ve 
presented reference this.  It’s black and white.  I’m not stupid.  I get it.  I get all the 
circumstantial stuff.  I understand that, but my answer’s not gonna [sic] change. From the first 
interview, from the three times I’ve said it now, it’s gonna [sic] be the same answer.”202 
 
J. Mutuku said he respected Detmer and me, “but my answer is—there’s nothing’s gonna [sic] 
make me change my answer. Uh, that’s—my answer’s what it is.” 
  
I explained prints had not yet come back on the frame of the flyer, but all the evidence items 
collected had also been swabbed for DNA.  I explained the frame was not an item stocked 
at the Department.  Since J. Mutuku maintained he was not responsible for the flyers, I asked 
if he would be willing to voluntarily supply a buccal swab to collect a sample of his DNA to 
show his DNA was not on the frame.  Mutuku answered “yes.”  He said he would have no 
problem doing that but said he may have touched a locker on his way out of the locker 
room.203   
He continued, “But usually, like, special cases that somebody brought and put, that aren’t… 
don’t usually belong there, then, then, there’s no reason for me… my DNA to be anywhere 
on there, and I have no problem with providing a buccal swab.204 
 
Detmer explained to J. Mutuku three different fingerprint examiners compared and confirmed 
J. Mutuku’s prints were located on the flyer inside the vinyl or plastic frame. 
 
I moved on and asked J. Mutuku why he drove to the swap meet to tell 
 to log on instead 
of calling him on the phone or radio.  J. Mutuku said he wanted to make sure 
 was 
physically there.  I told him I was curious about this because when he did that, there were 
 
201 J. Mutuku Interview 2, approximate time index 12:30; page 10 of transcript. 
202 J. Mutuku Interview 2, approximate time index 14:00; page 11 of transcript. 
203 J. Mutuku Interview 2, approximate time index 18:15; page 14 of transcript. 
204 J. Mutuku Interview 2, approximate time index 18:45; page 14 of transcript. 
Complainant
Complainant
Complainant
386

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.