434 - BR3_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Redacted_Attachment_B.pdf
About this document
- Layer
- packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
- Type as titled
- case_attachment (kind from hand)
- File
- 0b59e47e939063f8938332267911cbb97f962b8a application/pdf
- Cases
About: James Mutuku (case)
were not in roll call, not in the parking lot with a bunch of officers around, or in the field with a bunch of citizens around. A private conversation or “banter” was totally fine, but there had to be a certain level of respect. Barney said, “At some point, if I’m not asking you to do something illegal, immoral, or unethical, I really didn’t care what your opinion is. Go do it. Simple as that.” That was in line with our rank structure even though someone may not like it at times. He said he has not liked it at times, but he also knew it wasn’t his choice; he wasn’t asked to do anything illegal, immoral, or unethical, so he did it.
Barney said he could “100%” see how [Complainant] was the problem here and said he believed it was just [Complainant] frustration with the way things were run today. Barney has told [Complainant] he couldn’t look at it like that. He had a really good conversation about two weeks ago. He described he heard something happened between [Complainant] and Officer 3. He asked Officer 3 about it and Officer 3 told him he handled it and it was fine but was frustrated because he shouldn’t always have to justify himself to his officer. Barney called [Complainant] and asked him how he was doing and what was going on. He told [Complainant] “This isn’t the [Complainant] I remember.” They had a good conversation and Barney told him at the end of the day, [Complainant] needed to follow direction as long as it wasn’t illegal, immoral, or unethical. He told [Complainant] he was leaving in six months and to “stop arguing with my sergeants please.” [Complainant] shook his hand before he walked out and hasn’t done it since.
Barney has always gotten along with [Complainant] even though he doesn’t always agree with his thinking. He said not that it won’t happen again, but [Complainant] hasn’t with Barney’s sergeants since that conversation.
Barney thought it was good [Complainant] and Weddle were separated from riding partners. He and Officer 3 had talked about this before. It was their job to guide and manage the officers and make decision in the best interest of their careers. Weddle started to take on some disgruntled traits. Barney thought they were separated before any of these other things came to light and said it had nothing to do with that. Barney and Officer 3 had been about it for months. They were trying to see how things went, because [Complainant] and Weddle were both senior officers, but it was constant with little things here and there. Officer 3 thought they should be separated, and Barney told him to do it. Barney thought the separation occurred prior to [Complainant] coming to Internal Affairs about Officer 1 and Officer 2 but wasn’t sure.
As a watch commander, Barney likes two-person rides and would let them all go that way. He said it was proven to be safer and he preferred it. He didn’t mind having as many as he could go out there. It wasn’t a right to ride with a partner and he didn’t have to give you a reason why. People have been split before for a variety of reasons. He gave examples of wanting more cars in a beat and officers not doing what they should be doing when riding as partners. As a two-person ride, you should be faster than somebody riding solo and handling more reports. There were numerous reasons to separate a two-person unit and there wasn’t anything that said someone had a right to ride as a two-person unit.
I asked if there was an expectation of being more proactive as a two-person unit. Barney said there was nothing on paper in terms of expectations. As a watch commander, his perception of what a productive two-person unit looked like could be different than his five
Administrative Investigation: PC2211047 / Hostile Work Environment Claim
Page 82 of 155
336
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.