Documents › 0b59e47e939063f8938332267911cbb97f962b8a:255-409

434 - BR3_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Redacted_Attachment_B.pdf

POST board investigation reportagency investigation 2024-10-17 155 pages (file pages 255–409) original file
About this document
Layer
packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
Type as titled
case_attachment (kind from hand)
File
0b59e47e939063f8938332267911cbb97f962b8a application/pdf
Cases
POST 2303451 · James Mutuku (packet item)

About: James Mutuku (case)

Page 73 · file page 327 larger image
Image of page 73; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

McMahon could tell Officer 4 was "pretty pissed off." McMahon did not know where the coward comment came from. He also did not know who Complainant wanted to make the complaint against.

McMahon has not witnessed any behavior by supervision toward Complainant that he considered to be hostile or retaliatory. He has not witnessed any behavior by Complainant toward supervision that he would consider to be hostile, disrespectful, or inflammatory. He said, "I think Complainant when he does his, whatever he's doing, he... he's pretty smart about it." Complainant does not lose his temper and is "pretty smart when he does stuff."

McMahon did not witness any rat photos at the Lincoln Station. He advised he was off work but did hear about it. He heard there was an exchange between Sergeant James Mutuku and Complainant over the weekend but did not hear details. He heard shortly after some Rat Busters photos appeared in some of the mailboxes; one of them being Complainant. McMahon said everyone assumed it was J. Mutuku, but he didn't know.

McMahon is not personal friends with any of the parties but described them as acquaintances. He described Complainant as a "known prankster" and has been since Complainant started. He gave examples of eating half a cookie and putting "snot rockets" on the walls in the bathroom. McMahon said Complainant was a hard worker but has slowed down – perhaps due to issues with supervision. Complainant is very smart and probably knows case law better than most sergeants and lieutenants.

When asked if Complainant had a reputation for being a difficult employee, McMahon answered, "I think he does." McMahon didn't think this was the case years ago but said as Complainant has gotten older and closer to retirement, he seems like he is more of "a thorn in everyone's side." Complainant does it to "piss people off or ruffle feathers." McMahon said, "He's going to be known as a hard, and difficult employee" and Complainant used to be known as a hard worker. He said, "I think that's more his legacy now, unfortunately."

For most of McMahon's career, he has worked day shift and Complainant has worked swing shift. They have worked overtime shifts together though. McMahon has noticed Complainant has become more difficult over the years.

McMahon has worked under Officer 4 supervision or command and described him as jokester and one that would make "off-color" jokes occasionally. The things that Officer 4 may say do not affect McMahon because he knows how this profession is but said some of the things may offend some of the newer officers. He could not give a specific example, but said Officer 4 just had an old school mentality and was former military. McMahon has never seen Officer 4 treat someone in an unprofessional or hostile manner. Officer 4 did raise his voice at Complainant when he told Complainant to get out of the roll call room, but McMahon said it was obvious there was an issue between them. He did not think Officer 4 was being hostile or disrespectful to Complainant.

I asked McMahon if it was acceptable behavior for an officer to yell at a sergeant and call him a coward multiple times. He said no and these conversations should be held in private.

Administrative Investigation: PC2211047 / Hostile Work Environment Claim
Page 73 of 155

327

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.