434 - BR3_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Redacted_Attachment_B.pdf
About this document
- Layer
- packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
- Type as titled
- case_attachment (kind from hand)
- File
- 0b59e47e939063f8938332267911cbb97f962b8a application/pdf
- Cases
About: James Mutuku (case)
Smith is personal friends with Officer 4 and hung out with him outside of work. He considered J. Mutuku a work friend but did not hang out with him outside of work. I asked if Smith's relationship with Officer 4 affected what he shared during his interview to make things more favorable for Officer 4. He answered, "This is my honest opinion and observations during that period of time."
I asked Smith to describe Complainant as an employee. Smith believed Complainant had some level of respect for him and outside of their disagreement about Officer 1 and Officer 2 riding together, they got along just fine. Smith can see Complainant doesn't respect the other sergeants, would be happy not having a sergeant and believed he would be a better sergeant. Smith told Complainant to become a sergeant and come help. Complainant is difficult because he questions decisions constantly and this becomes problematic. During roll call, Complainant will challenge sergeants in front of other officers. Smith has had conversations with him about this and asked Complainant to talk to the sergeants and maybe add his additional information at a future roll call. However, that is not Complainant style and Smith believes Complainant believes "he's just better than us." Smith doesn't find him difficult because he doesn't care about Complainant opinion. He said, "Unfortunately, this is how bad it's gotten. But he... yeah, I don't want him to work for me. And like I said, I... I get along with him for the most part, but I don't want to supervise him." As a supervisor there are so many moving parts and things that require your attention. With Complainant this is difficult because he challenges everything. There are new officers that need to be taught officer safety, case law, policy, arrest, and control procedures, etc. Smith said he could not constantly be worried about Complainant opinion or unhappiness with Smith's decision. There are times as a supervisor you need to make command decisions and you don't need to be questioned constantly.
Smith and Complainant worked out at the same time and during these times, Smith told Complainant he should take on more of a leadership role. Smith talked to him about working with the sergeants and also offered to read Complainant opening and closing statement for the sergeant's interview. Complainant told him he was still working on it. Smith and Officer 3 also gave him a date and time so they could do a mock interview with Complainant and sent a text reminding him of the mock interview the day before, but Complainant called in sick. Smith and Officer 3 took time out of their day to make a series of questions, discuss them, and print them out for Complainant but he never showed. They did this for both Complainant and Weddle. It was obvious to Smith that Complainant was not going to interview for the position even though Complainant had not officially withdrawn from the process. Smith described Complainant as ungrateful and said he did not realize the time and effort made by him and Officer 3 to help him. Smith was done helping Complainant with the testing process after that. Smith heard Complainant sent an email to personnel just before his interview and withdrew from the process. However, Complainant never sent a text or email to Smith about the mock interview before or after he called in sick. He never apologized or asked if he could reschedule.
While Smith was on the SWAT Team, Complainant put in for the SWAT Team one or two times and failed to show up for the physical fitness test. Smith also heard Complainant had put in for the POP (Problem Oriented Policing) Team but withdrew prior to the interview. While Smith was the sergeant for the PACT Team, Complainant told him he was going to put in to be on that team, but never ended up putting in for the position. Smith didn't know if Complainant did these things to get a rise out of people but said Complainant follow through has always been incomplete.
Administrative Investigation: PC2211047 / Hostile Work Environment Claim
Page 65 of 155
319
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.