434 - BR3_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Redacted_Attachment_B.pdf
About this document
- Layer
- packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
- Type as titled
- case_attachment (kind from hand)
- File
- 0b59e47e939063f8938332267911cbb97f962b8a application/pdf
- Cases
About: James Mutuku (case)
I asked if [Complainant] had a reputation for being a difficult employee. Tipre answered, "yes" based on conversations he has had with other supervisors. He said [Complainant] liked to challenge things, so it was becoming a little more difficult to supervise him. However, Tipre has not witnessed this behavior on scenes.121
I asked Tipre if he ever witnessed [Complainant] speak to a sergeant in an antagonistic or inflammatory manner. Tipre said he would not describe it as either of those terms, but instead provided an example of behavior he had witnessed firsthand that he had never seen before. He described [Complainant] walked into the sergeant's office, walked up to [Officer 3] told him his evaluation was due, and he expected an outstanding rating. Tipre had never witnessed an officer come to a sergeant with an expectation of their evaluation. [Officer 3] told [Complainant] he was sure [Complainant] would have supporting documentation to justify this rating. [Complainant] told [Officer 3] he was his supervisor so he should know what [Complainant] does. Tipre described words were exchanged back and forth between [Complainant] and [Officer 3]. This took Tipre by surprise. He again said he had never seen this before and described it as "unique." Tipre said this occurred around September of this year.122
Tipre said he witnessed this firsthand, but only heard thirdhand about other incidents involving [Complainant]. I asked if the people who shared with him incidents involving [Complainant] would have any reason to lie. He answered, "No."
I asked Tipre if based on his personal observations of [Complainant] and what he has heard, he would want to have [Complainant] on his crew. I mentioned [Complainant] was knowledgeable in case law and very knowledgeable about the gangs in the city, especially Casa Blanca. Tipre acknowledged that [Complainant] was very knowledgeable but said he was headstrong, condescending, and liked to challenge things which could be detrimental to younger officers. It was also very time consuming to deal with this as a sergeant. If he had a senior officer that was a very good mentor, he would want them on his crew, to help mentor the younger officers. But this was not the case when you had a senior officer that was very headstrong and condescending. He advised [Complainant] comes off as negative and disgruntled to the junior officers and would be a negative influence.123
Tipre has not witnessed any behavior by supervision toward [Complainant] that would be considered hostile or retaliatory. Other than [Complainant] interaction with Zackowski in the parking lot, Tipre has not witnessed any actions by [Complainant] toward supervision that he would consider hostile or inflammatory.
Tipre described there was also a confrontation between [Complainant] and [Officer 4] that took place after the confrontation between [Complainant] and Zackowski. He advised [Complainant] returned to the roll call room and approached [Officer 4] with some paperwork. Tipre and Zackowski were seated in the elevated positions in the roll call room and [Officer 4] stood in front of them. [Complainant] told [Officer 4] he was putting him on notice he felt retaliated against. [Officer 4] told [Complainant] he could take that to the captain. [Complainant] told him per policy, he had to notify him. [Officer 4] advised [Complainant] since his complaint was against him, he could take it to the next level. [Complainant] left the roll
121 Tipre's Interview, approximate time index 21:55.
122 Tipre Interview, approximate time index 22:30.
123 Tipre Interview, approximate time index 27:30.
Administrative Investigation: PC2211047 / Hostile Work Environment Claim
Page 55 of 155
309
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.