736 - BR05_POST2311370_Zavala Jose_Attachment D - COP IntradeptMemo_Redacted.pdf
About this document
- Layer
- packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
- Type as titled
- case_attachment (kind from title)
- File
- 08aacc9b28e2b96616efca444250d5eae909b5eb application/pdf
- Cases
About: Jose Zavala (case)
The Honorable Board of Police Commissioners
Page 20
3.2
Officer 1 Him attacking my partners.32
The UOFRB assessed Officer 1's use of less-lethal force. As it pertains to his first round, the Board noted that per Tactics Directive 17.1, officers who encounter an armed self-mutilating or suicidal individual shall not use a 40mm LLL against that person, unless the officers reasonably believe the use of the 40mm LLL would not place the officers in a position which could escalate the situation to the use of lethal force. Per the directive, if officers choose to use a 40mm LLL in these situations, they should utilize distance and cover to avoid placing themselves in a vulnerable position. The Board noted that Officer 1 observed Victim holding the knife against his neck and his palm. Based on Victim's actions, Officer 1 opined that he was attempting or was going to attempt to cut himself with the knife. To prevent Victim from self-mutilating, Officer 1 discharged one round from his 40mm LLL, striking Victim. While the impact round did not seem to cause Victim any pain, the Board noted that he sat on the steps allowing officers several more minutes to attempt to de-escalate the situation. As indicated above, the UOFRB Majority opined that all of the officers had sufficient cover and distance when Officer 1 discharged his first impact round. Based on the totality, the Board opined that Officer 1's first use of the 40mm LLL conformed to Department policy.
Regarding Officer 1's second round, the Board noted that Victim had knocked the hat off his head, quickly stood holding the knife in the air, and looked toward his family members gathered in their front yard. According to the BWV footage, Victim took four steps toward Officer 1 and then turned to his left. At that moment, Officer 1 announced, "Forty, standby" as Sergeant announced "Forty, forty up!"33 In response, Officer 1 fired a second round from the 40mm LLL at Victim to prevent him from attacking officers. According to Officer 1 he believed that Victim was going to attempt suicide by cop and he was going to try to attack officers with the knife. Based on Victim's actions, the UOFRB opined that it was reasonable for Officer 1 to believe he posed an immediate threat to officers' safety when he discharged his second impact round.
In terms of the less-lethal warning, the Board noted that Officer 1 was not sure if one was given; however, he was aware that Sergeant had given the "40 stand by" command. Based on the totality of the circumstances, the Board opined that Officer 1 was confused as to whether a use of force warning had been given and may have mistaken the "40 stand by" command as a warning. The Board also opined that this issue could be addressed during the tactical debrief and that his use of less-lethal force was within policy.
Officer 1 recalled,
DETECTIVE GOLAN: Do you know if any use of force warning was given?
Officer 1 I'm not sure.34
32 Officer 1's transcript, Page 28, Lines 21-24.
33 Per the FID report, Sergeant directed Officer 1 to fire the 40mm LLL (second round). Based on Sergeant's BWV footage and statement to FID, the Board determined that he did not direct Officer 1's second discharge.
34 Officer 1's transcript, Pages 20-21, Lines 25-2.
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.